Which Murderer?
Which Murderer
Which Murderer brings together two hosts who talk about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer they would pick to kill them if they HAD to choose.Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Garry (the Scot) from Scotland.Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/)Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer)Explicit content and subject matter.
FLASHBACK EPISODE: Children that Murder
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!In Which Murderer’s Episode 41 Season 5 the girls cover chilling cases of Children Who Murder. Holly starts us off with the shocking case of Alyssa Bustamonte before Mel goes into the unbelievable murder by Amarjeet Sada. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Blink twice if you are in danger. In this episode you will go around the world with a tour of German foods (that actually aren’t German) and apologies to India…again. Mel gets pretty mad at numbers, you wil
FLASHBACK EPISODE: Murders Solved by Psychics
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle. Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job. Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains on a health not-kick, we learn that Holly skates like a sailboat
FLASHBACK EPISODE: Murderers Haunted by Ghosts
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!In Season 3 Episode 44 the girls talk about Murderers Haunted by Victim’s Ghosts. Gemma starts you off with the case of Adrian Daou before Holly goes over Jose Ferreira’s story. Shoutout for Scott who is smitten with Producer Craig apparently. The girls are trying not to let Craig hear his praise or he will take over and kick them out of the team. The girls are engrossing you all with endless stories of Wotsits, Holly weighs in on Gemma’s case and comes down on C
FLASHBACK EPISODE: Decapitation Murders
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!In Episode 26 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who lost their heads!....while decapitating people. Gemma covers the murderer Mathew Borges who took 'troubled teens' a step or ten too far and Holly speaks about the Kingsbury Run murders from the 1930s. The girls plug Gemma's guest appearance on the podcast 'Good Nurse Bad Nurse', Holly has another Reddit breakdown, the girls guess a movie correctly for the first time in history (wink wink Kevin Costn
FLASHBACK EPISODE: Edinburgh Unsolved Murders
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!In Season 3 Episode 7 – Edinburgh Unsolved Murders, Holly kicks off the local tales of Murder with the sad story of the lovely Anne Ballantine. Gemma then goes on to cover the murder of Helen Kane – with some pretty big potential serial killer links. Shoutout to a lovely Facebook follower who gave some feedback on our ‘Murders that Shocked the World’ episode – she spells her name very Irishy. There are opposite weather conditions in Edinburgh as per usual, math m
FLASHBACK EPISODE: 1970's Murders
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!In Season 3 Episode 14 –1970’s Murder – Gemma covers ‘Bad Man’ Randy Kraft while Holly tells you all about Robert John Maudsley who we might like a little? Shoutouts for some lovely iTunes reviewers including ‘Canadian Danni and Super Husband Clive’In this episode Gemma goes and ruins Holly’s favourite pasta, Holly gives some amazing Serial Killer pro tips, three entire adults fail to math, we conclude that 12 kids is too many kids and there are no pet budgies al
FLASHBACK EPISODE: New Years Murders
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!In Season 4 Episode 29 the girls wish you a very happy 2022 with MURDER. New Years Murders to be exact. Holly talks about murderer Scott Watson before Mel tells you all about John Allen Mohammad.The girls continue with the Covid chat which annoys them both, they touch their microphones a lot in this episode so…. good luck listeners, the girls tell you how much they hate New Years Eve but also have a great New Years Eve everyone, Holly chooses a challenging case i
FLASHBACK EPISODE: Christmas Murders
Which Murderer Flashback Episode!Merry/Happy Christmas everybody! Our 30th episode focuses on Christmas murders....we discuss the tragic murder of Joanna Yeates and the Christmas Day massacre committed by Bruce Pardo. We realise that Holly is way too presumptuous to sit on a jury. Holly also completely traumatises Gemma and she will never look at Santa the same again. Then we propose a new mating ritual that is bound to be successful with the human race.Production, recording and mixing completed
S7 EPISODE 2: Mistaken Identity Murder
In Season 7 Episode 2 Holly and Gary talk about Mistaken Identity Murders. Garry kicks things off with the story of Martin Trayton Smith before Holly talks about Rishmeet Singh. Shoutout to Emma Jo for this week’s topic suggestion! Thanks so much. The co-hosts are riddled with plague and are very poor babies who need their beds, Holly’s OCD carries over into the swimming pool, the metric system strikes again, and the dying prowess of Rambo is reviewed. WE ARE THE LAST GENERATION TO UNDERSTAN
S7 EPISODE 1: TV Special Murders
In Which Murderer’s first official episode of Season 7, the gang covers TV Special Murders. Holly starts us off with the case of Jennifer Ann Mee, before Garry goes over the tale of Brynn Omdahl Hartman. Listener Mel suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! This week there is TV series catchup with blatant spoilers, lovely listener messages which are butchered, hiccup cures are provided and there are too many N's.Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who is spoiling e
S7 EPISODE 0: Murdered by Proxy
LISTENER ANNOUNCEMENT: It’s a boy! Welcome Garry for Season 7!In Which Murderer’s opening episode of Season 7, the gang covers Murdered by Proxy. Garry starts us off with the case of John Bodkin Adams, before Holly goes over the tale of Mark Hopkinson. Listener Saraid suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! This week Holly recounts her summer (most of which she can’t remember), Garry starts his podcasting journey and drugs make another ill advised appearance. Production, recording and pos
FLASHBACK EPISODE: Witch Murders
WHICH MURDERER FLASHBACK EPISODE!In Which Murderer’s Episode 44 Season 5 the girls finally cover Witch Murders. Mel starts us off with Ama Hemmah from Ghana before Holly goes into the complicated case of Lawrence Harris. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion!In this episode the girls decide who the next James Bond will be and what TV Witches they want to drink some tea with, Mel is very clearly making up the name of her murderer entirely, Holly is queen of fire and the girls once again deliberat
FLASHBACK EPISODE: Psychics & Murder
IT'S A WHICH MURDERER FLASHBACK!In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle. Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job. Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains on a health not-kick, we learn that Holly skates like a sailboat,
S6 EPISODE 51: Vengeance Murders
LISTENER ANNOUNCEMENT: THIS WILL BE THE FINAL EPISODE OF SEASON 6 AS WE ARE NOW ON OUR SUMMER BREAK. WE WILL BE BACK IN SEPTEMBER! Stay safe and keep those episode suggestions coming in!In Which Murderer’s 51st episode of Season 6, the girls cover Vengence Murders. Holly starts us off with the gangland murder of Bailey Atkinson, before Mel goes over the tale of poor Keith Philpott. Listener Emma Jo suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! This week the girls would like to know who you are g
S6 EPISODE 50: Body Snatcher Murders
In Which Murderer’s 50th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Body Snatcher Murders. Mel starts us off with the world famous Burke and Hare Murders, before Holly goes over the closely related tale of the London Burkers.Listener Ricky suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! The weather girls (sorry, women) are covering ground breaking issues like murderous highland cows, resting livers, dead body shortages and how alcohol and drugs are definitely the way forward. Gentle but firm reminder to
S6 EPISODE 49: Care Home Murders
In Which Murderer’s 49th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Care Home Murders. Holly starts us off with the drug fueled case involving Rachel Baker, before Mel goes over the ‘angel of death’ story of Heather Pressdee. Listener Kirsty suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! This week's episode begins with memory failure, involves Eurovision, some very good advice regarding drugs (don’t do them kids!) and Holly is a time travelling wizard.Production, recording and post production completed
S6 EPISODE 48: Security Officer Murders
In Which Murderer’s 48th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Security Guard Murders. Mel starts us off with the controvercial case involving Jemel Robertson, before Holly goes over the horrifically violent story of James Airlie. Listener Karen suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! This week's episode begins with your usual weather update, Holly’s drama-filled journey to the middle of nowhere, preparations for the girls Eurovision Song Contest party and travel tales with burning skin.Pro
S6 EPISODE 47: Murdered & Fed to Animals
In Which Murderer’s 47th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Murdered and Fed to Animals. Holly starts us off with the disturbing case involving Svetlana Batukova, before Mel goes over the disgusting story of Susan Monica. Dr. Demi suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! This weeks episode has a handmaideny start, with Holly galavanting on roofs and Mel being drugged and lost on the trains. We also are told again what fans the girls are of prescription drugs. Production, recording and pos
S6 EPISODE 46: Boobytrap Murders
In Which Murderer’s 46th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Boobytrap Murders. Mel starts us off with the explosive case involving Ronan Kerr, before Holly goes over the crazy story of Anthony Edward Martin and Bleak House. Emma Jo suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! In this week’s episode there is far too much weather related moaning, we learn Holly has a background in Boobytraps, some sweeping (and likely inaccurate) terrorist statements are made and dental traumas are recounted. P
S6 EPISODE 45: Bigamous Murders
In Which Murderer’s 45th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Bigamous Murders. Holly starts us off with the horrifying case involving Rhonda Carlson, before Mel goes over the crimes and marriages of Jill Coit. BIG BOLD WARNING: This week there are graphic depictions of infant/child death that may disturb some listeners. Discretion is advised.Ricky suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!In this week’s episode the girls talk through their Easter activities and hormones, Blackpool has some q
S6 EPISODE 44: Personnel Murders
In Which Murderer’s 44th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Personnel Murders. Mel starts us off with the horrifying and shocking Maywand district murders, before Holly goes over the crimes of Allan Grimson. Dave suggested this week’s topic - SCIENCE ISN’T FUNNY DAVE! In this week’s episode the girls are rocking the pink life for a good thematic cause, face gems are the gift that keeps on giving from sweaty heads and Dave gets yelled at. Production, recording and post production completed by H
S6 EPISODE 43: Scientology Murders
In Which Murderer’s 43rd episode of Season 6, the girls cover Scientology Murders. Holly starts us off with the frustrating story of Lisa McPherson, before Mel goes over the also entirely preventable Elli Perkins case. Holly suggested this week’s topic - if she disappears search the Scientology ships! In this week’s episode the girls are lasagna filled, Holly is confused as to why it is ALL NAUTICAL, Mel likes people named Germany and the girls have some very strong uh-pinions on the Scientology
S6 EPISODE 42: Mistaken Identity Murders
In Which Murderer’s 42nd episode of Season 6, the girls cover Mistaken Identity Murders. Mel starts us off with the tragically sad story of Ronan Kanda, before Holly goes over the also very sad and long Crystal Theobald case.Saraid suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! In this week’s episode the girls go over yet more travel plans, there is a discussion around ninja knives (ninjas not included), gang life leads to chilli farming and there is some amazing CPR done.Production, recording an
S6 EPISODE 41: The Devil Made Me Do It
In Which Murderer’s 41st episode of Season 6, the girls cover The Devil Made Me Do It Murders. Holly starts us off with the gruesome story of Michael Taylor, before Mel goes over the famous Arne Cheyenne Johnson case.Dr. Demi suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! In this week’s episode Mel is back from her own personal Disneyland - aka Liverpool - after almost killing her husband with cringe, there are graveyard tales from Holly and Rosie the podcast dog and there is a tongue mystery tha
S6 EPISODE 40: Supermarket Murders
In Which Murderer’s 40th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Supermarket Murders. Mel starts us off with the story of Payton Gendron, before Holly goes over the Zane Michael Floyd case. . Kirsty suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much! In this week’s episode the chiropractor finally gets some love and more work than he anticipated from Mel, the girls have some concerns about America, we learn a new word (cheeple) and special guest star Rosie gives her two cents.Production, recording and po
S6 EPISODE 39: Hitmen - They Murder
In Which Murderer’s 39th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Hitmen - They Murder. Holly starts us off with the old timey french assassin Charlotte Corday, before Mel goes gangster with the crimes of Jimmy Moody.Dave suggested this week's episode - we think because of TV but maybe just cause he’s a super smart guy. THANKS DAVE!In this week’s episode there is a bit of confusion at the start (on how to start), there are some more TV recommendations, turns out old timey French people liked a long
S6 EPISODE 38: Manhunt Murders
In Which Murderer’s 38th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Manhunt Murders. Mel starts us off with the manhunt for Raoul Moat, before Holly fills you in on the crimes and chasing of Christopher Dorner. Holly suggested this week's episode - but she can’t remember why. And we can’t remember why. In this week’s episode there is head on car rage with technical difficulties, rogue sheep, royal rumours, very confused celebrity footballers and hostage fees are discussed. Both girls are not going to
S6 EPISODE 37: LGBTQ+ Murders
In Which Murderer’s 37th episode of Season 6, the girls cover LGBTQ+ Murders. Holly starts us off with the case of Scott Johnson the genius mathematician, before Mel fills you in on the sad story of Daniel Zamudio. Karen suggested this week's episode - thanks so much!In this week’s episode spring has sprung and the Easter Bunny is on his way….to be promptly eaten by Mel. The country of Switzerland is no longer safe either as she has learned of a special chocolate factory waiting for her….Holly m
S6 EPISODE 36: Paranormal Murders
In Which Murderer’s 36th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Paranormal Murders. Mel starts us off with a story about the Hammersmith Ghost, before Holly terrifies you with the Greenbrier Ghost story. Emma Jo suggested this week's episode - thanks so much! It was a blast to research. In this week’s episode you find out that Holly quote, ‘loves paranormal shit!’, Jesus is claimed, there are some excellent TV recommendations, you are advised not to wear white and Holly wants to name your babies
S6 EPISODE 35: Murders Solved by Tire Tracks
In Which Murderer’s 35th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Tire Track Murders. Holly starts us off with a case involving Sean Vincent Gillis, before Mel tells you all about the Russell Williams story. Dr Demi suggested this week's episode - thanks so much!This week the snow hating podcast covers upcoming trips, makeup and misunderstandings. The girls outdo themselves with memory struggles and Mel discusses her great football trauma.Production, recording and post production completed by Holly
S6 EPISODE 34: Murdered With No Trace
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the World’s First Productivity Shots!Visit www.magicmind.com/murderer and enter code MURDERER20 for great discounts!In Which Murderer’s 34th episode of Season 6, the girls cover cases where victims were Murdered with No Trace. Mel starts us off with a Tom Hardy case involving Jack 'the hat' McVitie, before Holly tells you all about the Michelle Mockbee story. Canadian Natalie suggested this week's episode - thanks so much!This week the sleepy podcast bri
S6 EPISODE 33: Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the World’s First Productivity Shots!Visit https://www.magicmind.com/murderer and use code MURDERER20 for great discounts!In Which Murderer’s 33rd episode of Season 6, the girls cover the incredibly important topic of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW). Holly starts us off with a sad case involving Destiny Tom, before Mel tells you all about Cheryl Ann Joe whose death inspired a memorial march. Autumn (love the name) suggested this week's epis
S6 EPISODE 32: Murderers Who Kill Again
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the World’s First Productivity Shots!In Which Murderer’s 32nd episode of Season 6, the girls cover Murderers Who Kill Again. Mel starts us off with a complicated ethical case involving John Staffen, before Holly tells you all about Kenneth McDuff and his terrible crimes.Kirsty who is in fact NOT FROM SCOTLAND suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!In this episode we find out it is the month of the birthday, there are some disturbing chiropractor re
S6 EPISODE 31: Furniture Murders
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the World's First Productivity Shot!In Which Murderer’s 31st episode of Season 6, the girls cover Furniture Murders. Holly starts us off with a case involving Troy Scott Johnston, before Mel tells you all about Tommy Zeigler.Holly suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much for a terrible idea Holly! This is why the girls cannot be trusted with picking topics. In this episode it’s very dark and the girls feel compelled to tell you about everything they
S6 EPISODE 30: Recorded Murders
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the world's first productivity shot!In Which Murderer’s 30th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Recorded Murders. Mel starts us off with a recent case involving Daniel White, before Holly tells you all about the shocking murderers Richard Davis & Dena Riley.Mel’s Co-Workers suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much and huge high fives for putting up with Mel!In this episode the girls are suffering through the longest month of the year (current d
S6 EPISODE 29: Judge Murders
This episode is sponsored by Magic Mind - the world's first productivity shot!In Which Murderer’s twenty ninth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Judge Murders. Holly starts us off with Canadian Judge Jacques Delisle, before Mel tells you all about the horrific murder of Cecilia Koranteng-Addow.Karen suggested this topic - thanks so much!In this episode the girls wish you a happy 2024 while Holly is still being tortured by 2023, the bad bad virus of 2023 has taken a toll, Mel resolved to stop
S6 EPISODE 28: Colour Murders
In Which Murderer’s twenty eighth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Colour Murders. Mel starts us off with the legendary case of the Black Dahlia, before Holly tells you all about the Red Barn murder from oldy times.Ricky suggested this topic……thanks Ricky!In this episode Holly tries to murder Mel by ‘making’ her record too many things, a certain flower gets butchered, Holly has new career plans as a Mole Catcher and there are some belated wishes from the girls.Production, recording and post
S6 EPISODE 27: Urban Legend Murders
In Which Murderer’s twenty seventh episode of Season 6, the girls cover Urban Legend Murders. Holly starts us off with the terrifying story of Janett Christman, before Mel tells you all about the murders committed by Andre Rand.Kirsty suggested this topic. We think this half of the murder twin duo is Scottish but we also think aliens exist and created math to slow down the human race so……In this episode it’s definitely Mel’s sleepy time., there have been some 3am shopping mistakes make, Mel acts
S6 EPISODE 26: Murdered in the Sunshine
In Which Murderer’s twenty sixth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Murdered in the Sunshine. Mel starts us off with the story of Leigh Leigh, before Holly tells you (again) all about the murder of Daniel James Morcombe. Both are tragic traumatic deaths of young people so listener caution is advised.Dave suggested this topic, but as he has abandoned Which Murder in favour of a lame award winning scientist he has received minus one thousand points. In this episode someone is both feral and shut
S6 EPISODE 25: Unlikely Murders
In Which Murderer’s twenty fifth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Unlikely Murders. We have a conspiracy theory, mystery and murder when Holly starts us off with the story of Rodney David Marks, before Mel tells you all about the unlikely assassination involving Stig Engstrom.Saraid suggested this episode topic - and she would like it known she WAS NOT BUYING DEEP FRIED PIZZA. In this episode you get a cosy weather update on Scotland, there is a review of a sequined night out followed by a
S6 EPISODE 24: Terrible Excuse Murders
In Which Murderer’s twenty fourth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Terrible Excuse Murders. One of them hits close to home for Mel who starts us off with the crazy story of John Wesley Hardin, before Holly tells you all about a family tragedy involving Fergus Glen.Mel suggested this one. She gets no shoutout because she can’t remember why she suggested it. In this episode the girls gift you a slow car crash, Holly has misplaced her ability to speak once again, there are wallpaper tit stories
S6 EPISODE 23: Mob Massacre Murders
In Which Murderer’s twenty third episode of Season 6, the girls cover Mob Massacre Murders. Holly starts us off with the brutal story of Farkhunda Malikzada, before Mel tells you all about the Rosewood Massacre.Shoutout to Emma Jo for the suggestion!In this episode the girls argue quite dramatically over bones and chiropractors, Holly reveals her cliffhanger which Mel is not impressed with, there is a rant about ‘ums’ and Holly’s mouth is broken in all the ways a mouth can break. Production, rec
S6 EPISODE 22: Blasphemy Murders
In Which Murderer’s twenty second episode of Season 6, the girls cover Blasphemy Murders. Mel starts us off with the story of Salman Taseer, before Holly tells you all about the old timey case involving Thomas Hawkes.Shoutout to Ricky (who may or may not listen) for the suggestion!In this episode the girls have some heated pumpkin patch debates, Mel experiences mouth struggles, Holly has stoma bag dreams and WTF are ‘furries’? Trust us you do not want to know. Production, recording and post prod
S6 EPISODE 21: Bite Mark Murders
In Which Murderer’s twenty first episode of Season 6, the girls cover Bite Mark Murders. Mel starts us off with the heartbreaking story of Megan Kanka - a brave little girl whose death has helped thousands more survive, before Holly tells you all about the case involving David Wayne Spence.Shoutout to Cheryl for the suggestion! Everyone send her some kind thoughts and good vibes.In this episode the girls try to explain why everything is out of sync but it’s honestly too confusing for them to com
S6 EPISODE 20: Water Murders
In Which Murderer’s twentieth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Water Murders. Holly starts us off again (don’t ask - the whole system is broken - everything is terrible) with the crimes of Oba Chandler before Mel tells you all about the murderer George Joseph Smith.Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Until the next rendezvous at the chippy….In this episode the girls discuss their terrifying lack of eyesight while driving at night, there is panic at the Christmas disco, some riveting insur
S6 EPISODE 19: Honey Trap Murders
In Which Murderer’s nineteenth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Honey Trap Murders. Holly starts us off with the sad trap executed on Vishal Gohel before Mel tells you all about the murder of Saul Murray.Shoutout to Caitlin for the suggestion! Literally. We yelled at you. In this episode the weather has turned and autumn is setting in, there are some drink discussions which of course the girls do not agree on, Holly reveals some interesting Amsterdam facts and 2022 is apparently the year of
S6 EPISODE 18: Magic Murders
In Which Murderer’s eighteenth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Magic Murders. Mel starts us off with the absolutely disgusting story of Ahmad Suradji before Holly tells you all about the ridiculous murderer Georgy Tarimanovich Martirosyan.Shoutout to Joanne for the suggestion!In this episode Mel recounts her near death experience in York, Holly tells you tales of absinthe, there are tales of cosmopolitan Glasgow and apologies in advance if you vomit during this one. It’s all Mel’s fault. Pr
S6 EPISODE 17: Murdered for the Wrong Name
In Which Murderer’s Seventeenth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Murdered For the Wrong Name. Holly starts us off with the story of Joanne Kitchen before Mel tells you all about the traumatic case involving Joanne Kitchen.Shoutout to our Murder Twins for the suggestion!In this episode there are disasters striking from all directions, the girls discover once again how hard medical words and math are and you will be introduced to Smellanie. Production, recording and post production completed b
S6 EPISODE 16: Murdered During Sex
In Which Murderer’s Sixteenth episode of Season 6, the girls cover People Murdered During Sex. Mel starts us off with the story of Taylor Schabusiness (apparently that’s a real name folks) before Holly tells you all about the horrific case involving murderer Sam Pybus.Shoutout to Carrie for the suggestion!In this episode you are presented with a coughing Mel, extremely tired Holly, the mid-recording death and resurrection of one of the girls and Mel magically turns Brazillian before the end of t
S6 EPISODE 15: 'Mr. Big' Murders
In Which Murderer’s Fifteenth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Mr. Big Murders. Not the character from 'Sex and the City'. Or the chocolate bar. Holly starts us off with the story of Dax Mack (cool name points) before Mel tells you all about the horrific crimes of Brett Peter Cowan.Shoutout to Mel for the suggestion! I guess. In this episode the girls talk why Mel keeps missing the microphone (hint, it involves stroking), how watching 'The Muppet Movie' is good for Holly, there is an impromp
S6 EPISODE 14: Campsite Murders
In Which Murderer’s Fourteenth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Campsite Murders. Mel starts us off with the story of Anthony Rauda before Holly tells you all about Trevor Holminski.Shoutout to Karen for the suggestion!In this episode the girls talk about Mel’s love of the great outdoors, what is a camping red flag, there is some Imagine Dragons karaoke inspired by the weather and Rosie the podcast dog tries to shut down production. Production, recording and post production completed by Holl
S6 EPISODE 13: Moron Murders
In Which Murderer’s Thirteenth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Moron Murders. Holly starts us off with the story of the moron known as Richard Kuklinski before Mel tells you all about dum-dum Robert Nixon.Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion! In this episode the girls talk about the ‘end times’ and how they are still pretty chipper all things considered, Mel abuses her microphone endlessly, the girls struggle with the topic of ‘moron murders’ ironically, before the decline in Australian li
S6 EPISODE 12: Soap Opera Murders
In Which Murderer’s Twelfth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Soap Opera Murders (the real kind). Mel starts us off with the story of actress Rebecca Schaeffer before Holly tells you all about the murderer Guilherme de Pádua.Shoutout to Emma Jo for the suggestion! And apologies to Brazil. So many apologies. In this episode the girls offer more valuable life advice, Holly goes from Fringe Festival hatred to Autumn season love, Mel is your TV Guide and it turns out Holly is a creep. Which we kn
S6 EPISODE 11: Murdered by a CoWorker
In Which Murderer’s eleventh episode of Season 6, the girls cover Murdered At Work. Holly starts us off with murderer Patrick Henry Sherill before Mel tells you all about the case involving Michael Carpenter. Shoutout to Jade for the suggestion!In this episode which is pretty focussed on chiropractors for very old lady reasons, you’ll hear about some pelvic splinting tips for Mel, a missing year and miraculous workplace tales of survival from the girls. Production, recording and post production
S6 EPISODE 10: Storage Locker Murders
In Which Murderer’s tenth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Storage Locker Murders. Mel starts us off with the currently developing Gilgo Beach Murders before Holly tells you all about the case the Benders. Shoutout to Kristi for the idea! Even if Mel hated it. In this episode Holly says ‘wow’ an annoying amount of times, Mel finds out Aliens are real (and that news doesn’t travel to France), there are cupboards of confusion and it’s revealed that Mel enjoys a sunburn and is probably a wrink
S6 EPISODE 9: Hurricane Murders
In Which Murderer’s ninth episode of Season 6, the girls cover Hurricane Murders. Holly starts us off with the enraging story of the Danziger Bridge shootings, before Mel tells you all about the case involving Rubin Carter. Shoutout to Cheryl for the inspiration! You can never go wrong with a meme. In this episode the girls discuss how everything is just fine (when it’s absolutely not), Mel is once again the queen of Covid, you will learn some amazing facts and experience a whistle stop tour of
S6 EPISODE 8: Murdered over Opinions
In Which Murderer’s eighth episode of Season 6, the girls cover people who were Murdered Over Opinions. Mel starts us off with the sad story of Brianna Ghey before Holly tells you all about the case involving Shannon Brandt. Shoutout to our good friend Betty for the suggestion! She probably won’t listen though so instead, the girls will thank themselves for being such great friends. In this episode the girls discuss their drinks for that night including Mel’s ‘classy’ new cocktail discovery, how
S6 EPISODE 7: Office Party Murders
In Which Murderer’s seventh episode of Season 6 the girls cover the extremely hard to research topic of Office Party Murders. Holly starts us off with killers Rizwan Farook & Tashfeen Malik before Mel tells you all about the frustrating case of Melanie Hall . Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion! Never torture us like this again. In this episode the girls are for once grateful about all their dental records, Mel diligently researches a fictional murder case, some red flags are at various le
S6 EPISODE 6: Familial DNA Murders
In Which Murderer’s sixth episode of Season 6 the girls cover the fascinating topic of Familial DNA Murders. Mel starts us off with murderer Lonnie David Franklin Jr. before Holly tells you all about the eventually solved case involving Joseph Kappen. Shoutout to Cheryl for the suggestion! In this episode the girls talk about Holly’s new electric wheels, how men are the absolute worst (when it comes to buying cars) and they advise all you children who should definitely not be listening to DO TH
S6 EPISODE 5: Gravedigger Murders
In Which Murderer’s fifth episode of Season 6 the girls cover Gravedigger Murders. Holly starts us off with the murder of Thomas Hollran who was run out of town before Mel tells you all about the hit TV show based on the case of Larry Hall. Shoutout to Karen for the suggestion! In this episode the girls are having some morning issues due to the fact they are organising, hosting and taking part in an outdoor festival, there are some case updates from Holly and you will go on a vocabulary journey
S6 EPISODE 4: Military Murders
In Which Murderer’s fourth episode of Season 6 the girls cover Military Murders. Mel starts us off with the infuriating murder of Vanessa Guillen before Holly tells you all about the emotional rollercoaster case of Frank Vanessa Guillen. Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion! Are you twin one or twin two?In this episode the girls are confident they have reached the peak of low, there is a great amount of yawning, Mel gets super annoyed with the US Military and Holly lists off a bunch of random m
S6 EPISODE 3: Wrestling Murders
In Which Murderer’s third episode of Season 6 the girls cover Wrestler Murders. Holly starts us off with the gangland style murder of Dino Bravo before Mel tells you all about the soapy murder of Frank Goodish. No shoiwer meetings!Shoutout to Emma Jo for the suggestion! In this episode the girls experience flashbacks to the glory days of professional wrestling, Holly pulls a muscle sitting, Mel is off to France and it turns out Hulk Hogan is alive after all.Production, recording and post product
S6 EPISODE 2: Celebrities Who Murder
In Which Murderer’s second episode of Season 6 the girls cover Celebrities Who Murder. Mel starts us off with the very famous case of Oscar Pistorius before Holly tells you all about the actor Michael Andrew Jace. Shoutout to Caitlin for the suggestion! Your baby has an excellent head. In this episode the girls are throwing Royalist Parties and Lodge Weekends, there is a mutual hatred for Mel’s celebrity and Holly is not a fan of bombings as it turns out.Production, recording and post production
S6 EPISODE 1: Murdered by Authority
WELCOME TO WHICH MURDERER SEASON 6!In Which Murderer’s first episode of Season 6 the girls cover Murdered by Authority. Holly starts us off with the case of Grant Hardin before Mel tells the mind twisting tale of Daniel Morgan. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! In this episode the girls start off as they usually do in a cloud of confusion, Mel celebrates the start of her third season with the podcast, Holly swallows a filling just prior to recording which leads us all down a rather unpleasa
BONUS EPISODE: Incels Who Kill
BONUS EPISODEWhich Murderer will return for Season 6 on 7 July, 2023. In Season 4 Episode 13 the girls cover a suggested topic from Season 1-3 Co-host Gemma – Incels Who Murder. AKA Involuntary Celibates. Holly starts things off with the poster boy for this group who was responsible for the 2014 Isla Vista murders before Mel chats through the case of Alek Minassian. Shout-out to Carrie for her lovely comments about Mel who is doing much better at checking Facebook occasionally. The girls are up
BONUS EPISODE: Psychics
BONUS EPISODEWhich Murderer will return for Season 6 on 7 July, 2023. In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle. Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job. Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains on a health not-kick, we le
BONUS EPISODE: Dentists Who Murder
BONUS EPISODEWhich Murderer will return for Season 6 on 7 July, 2023In Season 4 Episode 24 the girls talk about Dentists Who Murder - perfectly timed to be just before Mel’s dental appointment. Mel chats about Colin Howell before Holly tells you about Tony Protopappas. Shoutouts to listeners Mark and Robyn! KEEP SENDING YOUR TOPIC SUGGESTIONS. We are lazy. There are more updates on how dark it is in Scotland, dental traumas are revisited, Mel forgets major surgery that she had and the girls woul
SEASON FINALE! S5 EPISODE 52: Hidden Body Murders
WHICH MURDERER SEASON 5 FINALE!Thank you to all our amazing listeners, our lovely support teams at Spreaker, iHeart Radio, iTunes, Spotify and of course to our families who put up with us forcing them to watch True Crime at every opportunity. We will be taking a 3 week break (which you will hear us debating in this episode!) voted on by you, our listeners, in an online poll. We will be relaunching some of our favourite episodes during the break so stay tuned for those. In Which Murderer’s Episod
S5 EPISODE 51: Hospital Porter Murders
A message from the Which Murderer Team: It has been brought to our attention that ad space was sold to a political party in the US who released a campaign message we absolutely do not endorse. We apologise to our listeners and have worked with our network to remove all future Political ad options from our podcast feed. In Which Murderer’s Episode 51 Season 5 the girls cover Hospital Porter Murders. Holly starts us off with the brutal murder of David Hamilton before Mel tells the extremely distur
S5 EPISODE 50: Rising Star Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 50 Season 5 the girls cover Rising Star Murders. Mel starts us off with the tragic murder of Christina Grimmie before Holly tells the story of Lebanese rising star Suzanne Tamim. Shoutout to Natalie for the suggestion! Also Joanne - a blast from Mel’s past and new listener! In this episode the girls are so professional they forgot they were professional and became unprofessional rather quickly, Finland is cursed over listening figures, there is a long awaited sad pig
S5 EPISODE 49: House Party Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 49 Season 5 the girls cover House Party Murders. Holly starts us off with the killing of Luke Moran before Mel tells the story of parent killer Tyler Hadley. Shoutout to Caitlin for the suggestion! Also Karen and Emma Jo for all the other suggestions coming in! In this episode the girls are tired and broken, specifically Mel who cannot shower without a carer anymore, Holly tells you about a 12 hour unexpected border crossing, the girls reveal some personal house part
S5 EPISODE 48: Social Media Influencer Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 48 Season 5 the girls cover Social Media Influencer Murders. Mel starts us off with the subject of a recent Netflix documentary, Caleb McGillvary before Holly recounts the story of an incel named Brandon Andrew Clark. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Also Sarah from Alaska for her lovely message to us on Instagram. In this episode Mel pulls herself together to delivery a professional into which Holly ruins with her shockingly poor memory, there is crying over th
S5 EPISODE 47: Secret Society Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 47 Season 5 the girls cover Secret Society Murders. Holly starts us off with the history of the The Molly Maguires before Mel covers the recent scandal surrounding NXIVM.Shoutout to Carrie for the suggestion! Or Natalie. It was a rough night. In this episode buckle up for poor overworked Mel’s brain, some pretty great TV recommendations, a podcast recommendations and you’ll witness Consulting Producer Craig roll over in his grave. Despite still being alive. Oh and the
S5 EPISODE 46: Florist Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 46 Season 5 the girls cover the challenging topic Florist Murders. Mel starts us off cheeky with the case of Norman Flowers (see what she did there) before Holly covers the unsolved case of Jacob Bornkamp. Shoutout to Karen for the suggestion!If you have any information regarding the Jacob Bornkamp case please contact Crime Stoppers immediately. In this episode Mel is blind and doesn’t care how Holly is feeling, you are invited to visit a new place called ‘Nervada’, H
S5 EPISODE 45: Bodies in Concrete
WARNING! THIS EPISODE CONTAINS DETAILS OF CRIMES THAT ARE GRAPHIC AND EXTREMELY DISTURBING. LISTEN WITH CAUTION. In Which Murderer’s Episode 45 Season 5 the girls cover Bodies in Concrete. Holly starts us off with a very recent case in Scotland involving Andrew Innes before Mel retells the tale of poor Junko Furata. Shoutout to Natalie for the suggestion!In this episode the girls come to you from different furniture, Mel manages to complain despite being in a bed, surrounded by pillows and unde
S5 EPISODE 44: Witch Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 44 Season 5 the girls finally cover Witch Murders. Mel starts us off with Ama Hemmah from Ghana before Holly goes into the complicated case of Lawrence Harris. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion!In this episode the girls decide who the next James Bond will be and what TV Witches they want to drink some tea with, Mel is very clearly making up the name of her murderer entirely, Holly is queen of fire and the girls once again deliberate through worst fears. Not includ
S5 EPISODE 43: Murdered in Care
In Which Murderer’s Episode 43 Season 5 the girls cover heartbreaking cases of people Murdered in Care.Holly starts us off with wee Marcus Fiesel before Mel goes into the story of Leiland James Corkhill.Shoutout to Emma Jo for the suggestion!In this episode you will hear about old news updates that are now also probably old news, Mel learns that there is fruit that doesn’t come out of tins, a serious discussion on Adoption takes place as well as a good old fashioned ranty rant from Mel.Productio
S5 EPISODE 42: Murdered by Gas
In Which Murderer’s Episode 42 Season 5 the girls cover super awful cases of people Murdered by Gas. Mel starts us off with war criminal Joseph Mengele before Holly goes into the real time case of Genivaldo de Jesus Santo. Shoutout to Ricky who probably doesn’t listen to the podcast, for the suggestion. In this episode you will witness a very rare professional start, Holly has some door dramas then her car is used for stranger napping, Mel shares her booze fueled mishaps and you all get the ed
S5 EPISODE 41: Children that Kill
In Which Murderer’s Episode 41 Season 5 the girls cover chilling cases of Children Who Murder. Holly starts us off with the shocking case of Alyssa Bustamonte before Mel goes into the unbelievable murder by Amarjeet Sada. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Blink twice if you are in danger. In this episode you will go around the world with a tour of German foods (that actually aren’t German) and apologies to India…again. Mel gets pretty mad at numbers, you will get education you didn’t ask fo
S5 EPISODE 40: Solved with DNA
In Which Murderer’s Episode 40 Season 5 the girls cover Murders Solved with DNA. Mel starts us off with the very sad case of Anna Palmer before Holly goes into the murder by Terrence Miller. Shoutout to Michelle for the suggestion!In this episode there are more challenges to recording such as Mels face and Holly’s knees, you will hear all about Holly’s adorable new animals, TV Recommendations are made whether you want them or not, there is some weird breath holding followed by medical advice on
S5 EPISODE 39: Grifter Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 39 Season 5 the girls cover Grifter Murders. What is a Grifter Murder you ask? You’ll have to listen. Holly starts us off with the retelling of the case of Sante Kimes before Mel goes into the murder by Christian Gerhartsteiter. Shoutout to Natalie for the suggestion!In this episode Mel has to be physically removed from her phone, Holly is murdered by a chair which results in the girls using their one brain cell to come up with their own topic idea, Which Murderer be
S5 EPISODE 38: Nurses Who Murder
In Which Murderer’s Episode 38 Season 5 the girls cover Nurses Who Murder. Mel starts us off with the incredibly tragic case of Beverly Allitt before Holly goes into the horrible murders by Niels Högel. Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion!In this episode Mel is eating candy as per usual, Holly reveals her false teeth plan, you’ll learn more about how Holly’s body defies life and Mel brings out her character ‘Arm Flailer’. Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who has of
S5 EPISODE 37: Musical Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 37 Season 5 the girls cover Musical Murders. Holly starts us off with the surprising story of Marvin Gaye Jr. before Mel goes into the famous death of Beatle John Lennon.Shoutout to Caitlin for the suggestion!In this episode Holly makes third party baby demands, the podcast gets some lovely feedback from a victim’s daughter, Mel has on purpose chosen a case with a lot of work involved and you will be judged hard if you’ve never been to Liverpool apparently.Production,
S5 EPISODE 36: Cooking Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 36 Season 5 the girls cover Cooking Murders. Mel starts us off with the unbelievably horrific and sad case of Lamora Williams before Holly goes into the tragic death of Elivelton Dias. Shoutout to Saraid for the really interesting suggestion! And also to Natalie for more excellent memes.You are experiencing the 4th recording in a row this episode so buckle up, there are some revisited kitchen wars, a theme may or may not have been completely misinterpreted by Mel, Hol
S5 EPISODE 35: Murdered on a Plane
In Which Murderer’s Episode 35 Season 5 the girls cover people who were Murdered on a Plane. Holly starts us off with the grand-daddy of plane murderers Earnest P. Pletch before Mel goes into the Canadian murderer Albert Guay . Shoutout to Cheryl for the great suggestion! Who knew we could be even more afraid of air travel. Mel starts off with some unexpected professionalism followed by a current affairs update on a very hateable person who got caught via pizza - dumb prison story dude, Holly’s
S5 EPISODE 34: Prejudice Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 34 Season 5 the girls cover the important topic of Prejudice Murders. Mel starts us off with the tragic and historically important story of Emmett Till before Holly goes into the ongoing case of the Tree of Life Synagogue shooting. Shoutout to NEW MUMMY Caitlin for the great suggestion! And congrats on your beautiful baby boy. Also shoutouts to Mark and Emma Jo - thanks so much for the feedback and suggestions.In this episode you will get your long awaited squirrel a
S5 EPISODE 33: Grannies Who Murder
In Which Murderer’s Episode 33 Season 5 the girls cover Grannies Who Murder. Holly starts us off with the story of Tamara Samsonova before Mel goes into the case of Nannie Doss. Shoutout to Cheryl for the great suggestion! In the first recording session of 2023 the girls give you a Christmas recap which largely focuses on sickness - Merry Flu from Holly, Mel passes along some wisdom from her own Granny, Sally and Danny are thanked for their amazing reviews, we once again learn that keeping a di
S5 EPISODE 32: Murderers with Weird Names
In Which Murderer’s Episode 32 Season 5 the girls cover Murderers with Weird Names. Mel starts us off with the story of Vaughn Greenwood before Holly goes into the case of Joseph Douglas Ball. Shoutout to Carrie for the great suggestion! This episode Holly makes it clear we are NOT the football podcast, Mel is holding onto a killer map until her dying breath, Holly conducts a stupid-pigeon rescue, future Goldfish babies are named and there is surprising Burt Reynolds mail. Production, recording
S5 EPISODE 31: Noisy Neighbours
In Which Murderer’s Episode 31 Season 5 the girls cover Noisy Neighbour Murders. Holly starts us off with the story of Barry Williams before Mel goes into the case of Jamie Crosbie. Shoutout to Kirsty for the great suggestion! The girls gift you with a Mrs. Doubtfire greeting before quickly going into the tales of Holly’s Halloween recap which involved terrible neighbours, time travel once again takes place, there are some mind blowing name changes, a great out of date show recommendation and
S5 EPISODE 30: Murdered on a Beach
WARNING - EXPLICIT DESCRIPTIONS OF SEXUAL ASSAULT ARE CONTAINED IN THIS WEEKS EPSIDE. In Which Murderer’s Episode 30 Season 5 the girls cover Beach Murders. Mel starts us off with the Koh Tao Murders before Holly goes into the case of a hero named Khuram Shaikh. Shoutout to OG Listener Jade for the great theme suggestion! Holly kicks you off with some animal stories about possibly killing donkeys with mints, Mel experiences a potential King sighting, our deepest apologies to Thailand for thi
S5 EPISODE 29: Murderers Who Are Presumed Innocent
Happy New Year - and oddly Happy Halloween? In Which Murderer’s Episode 29 Season 5 the girls cover Murderers Who Were Presumed Innocent. Holly starts us off with an incredibly sad and tragic story involving Susan Smith before Mel goes into the case of Carlos de Luna. Shoutout to Cheryl for the great theme suggestion and a fabulous review by Stephanie! The girls compare Trick or Treating methods as well as some urban myths, you find out about the Great Canadian fear of eggs, Holly struggles t
S5 EPISODE 28: River Murders ~ MERRY CHRISTMAS! ~
Merry Christmas to our lovely listeners! We wish you all a very happy holiday season and a joyous new year. In Which Murderer’s Episode 28 Season 5 the girls cover River Murders. Mel starts us off with horrors of the Green River Killer before Holly goes into the monster named Joel David Rifkin. Shoutout to Kristy for the great theme suggestion! Mel begins with being unprepared and slowly sinking into the sofa….the usual, the girls chat about Christmas preparations, Mel asks a lot of question
S5 EPISODE 27: Mistaken Identity Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 27 Season 5 the girls cover Mistaken Identity Murders. Holly starts us off with the tragic story involving Chad Gordon before Mel goes into the injustice of the conviction of Joyce Ann Brown. Shoutout to Natalie for another great suggestion! Also we require more memes. The new Which Murderer fractions podcast covers off some early Christmas prep, the advice regarding London crime is very useful if you are going to be committing crime in London, Mel refuses to promote
S5 EPISODE 26: Murdered in Prison
In Which Murderer’s Episode 26 Season 5 the girls cover Murdered in Prison. Mel starts us off with the murder story involving Edwin Kaprat before Holly goes into the murder of the Black Movement hero Bantu Stephen Biko. Shoutout to Cheryl for another great suggestion!It’s the halfway episode! The girls have managed to make it halfway through Season 5 and are already planning the Season 6 schedule so get those theme suggestions in! Holly reveals to Mel her potential upcoming animal adoption which
BONUS GUEST EPISODE: Mums, Mysteries & Murder: The Loch Ness Monster
We can't believe we live in Scotland and have yet to cover the Loch Ness Monster, so here it is! This one is actually covered by Marti who was recently up at Loch Ness and inspired to do this ep. We would love to hear your thoughts on our ep and whether you believe in the monster of the deep!Again huge thanks to Erin our amazing podcast editor and a shout out to the Haunted or Hoax podcast featured at the beginning of our trailer, we love those ladies and were huge fans of the podcast!Sources
BONUS GUEST EPISODE: CrimeDivers - Murder On The Roadside
BONUS EPISODECRIME DRIVERS PODLee Harvey was murdered in a road rage incident, his fiancee Tracie Andrews claimed they were attacked by two men but the evidence said different. Our contact details are: Instagram & Twitter - crime_divers_pod Email - crime_divers_pod@outlook.com YouTube - CrimeDivers Podcast TikTok - crimediverspodcast If you would like to financially support the show: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/crimedivers If you would like bonus episodes or even just early access to our regula
S5 EPISODE 25: Murders of Passion
In Which Murderer’s Episode 25 Season 5 the girls cover Murders of Passion. Holly starts us off with the murder story involving Martha Freeman and her closet before Mel goes into the murder of David Lynn Harris. Shoutout to our glowing Caitlin for this week’s topic suggestion!Holly starts us off with her experience as a hotel manager this Thanksgiving, Mel decides it's time to become a private detective, Holly explains how her finger was almost lost as a direct result of a lazy mailman, the girl
S5 EPISODE 24: Bullied and Murdered
In Which Murderer’s Episode 24 Season 5 the girls cover Bullied and Murdered stories. Mel starts us off with the murder story involving Bobby Kent before Holly goes into the horrific crimes of Thomas Nutt. Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s topic suggestion!Mel hits a wall for the fourth recording of the evening and makes it weird, Holly updates you on all the animals, Mel struggles to say a word which Holly watches in fascination instead of helping and time travel occurs when the girls talk to
S5 EPISODE 23: Mormon Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 23 Season 5 the girls cover Mormon Murders. Holly starts us off with the origin story and original murder of Joseph Smith before Mel goes into the horrific crimes of Ron and Dan Lafferty. Shoutout to Betty who will never listen to this episode ever for the suggestion!Mel kicks things off with her best Tom Jones songs which go totally unappreciated, Holly recommends you find your Apocalypse Mormon Buddy ASAP, the 1800s were a crazy time for land pirates, and Scientolog
S5 EPISODE 22: Landlord Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 22 Season 5 the girls cover Landlord Murders. Please note murdering your landlord will not decrease your rent. Mel starts us off with the case of Helen McCourt before Holly goes into the story of Todd Greathouse. Which is the perfect name for a Landlord. Shoutout to Michelle for the episode suggestion! The girls take up time you will never get back telling you about some great TV shows on at time of recording (including one their weaker partners have refused to finish
S5 EPISODE 21: Food Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 21 Season 5 the girls cover Food Murders. This episode starts off with Holly telling you about Thomas Neill Cream (appropriate for this episode) before Mel goes into the story of Craig Godineux and John Taylor.Shoutout to Kristy for the episode suggestion! The girls are facing the realities of Christmas shopping budgets and £200 turkeys, Holly’s murderer has exactly one billion airmiles, as per usual the English language takes a beating and the topic makes both girls
S5 EPISODE 20: Twin Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 20 Season 5 the girls cover Twin Murders. This episode starts off with Mel telling you about Kevin and Karl Dugar before Holly recounts the story of Pete and Pat Bondurant.Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion - very interesting!Double trouble this episode with Mel just going for the opening and nailing it, Holly is put under car colour pressure, Mel is on a campaign to get a bus driver fired, the Dave Cafe opens at Mel’s house in the middle of nowhere and the girls a
S5 EPISODE 19: Catfish Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 19 Season 5 the girls cover Catfish Murders. This episode starts off with Holly telling you about Thomas Montgomery before Mel recounts the story of Jenelle Potter.Shoutout to Kirsty and Millie the Cat for the suggestion - fabulous tie in with your furry family member! Who hopefully cannot use a keyboard. Buckle up, these cases are INSANE. Like the people in them. This week the girls chat about the new King, Holly’s shady dating history, there is excellent safety inf
S5 EPISODE 18: Sleep Related Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 18 Season 5 the girls cover Murders Involving Sleep. This episode starts off with Mel telling you about Michael Ricksgers before Holly reveals an unusual tale from Spain, the story of Antonio Nieto.Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion that was impossible to research! Keep the challenges coming! This week we start off with the sad news of HM Queen Elizabeth II’s death, a recollection of the girls attending a talk by former Detective David Swindle on Catching Killers,
S5 EPISODE 17: Pigeon Murders
LISTENER WARNING - THIS EPISODE INCLUDE DESCRIPTIONS OF PIGEONS WHICH FOR SOME REASON MAKES PEOPLE LOSE THEIR SWEET MINDS. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED. LISTENER DISCRETION IS ADVISED WE GUESS?In Which Murderer’s Episode 17 Season 5 the girls cover Pigeon Murders to Holly’s delight! This car crash of an episode starts off with Holly telling you the story of Keith Walker which traumatises Mel given she researched the same case. By mistake. SHE IS NOT OK. Mel then does a spectacular recovery to bring you
S5 EPISODE 16: Gaming Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 16 Season 5 the girls cover Video Game Murders. Mel starts you off with the story of Daniel Petric before Holly talks about the very sad case of Breck Bednar. Shoutout to Garry for the interesting topic suggestion and excellent nightly shoulder rubs. Mel starts of with a non-murder related story of her charity shop adventures before rolling her eyes at Holly the Pigeon Behavioural Expert’s tale of her omnipotent birds, the girls give you some great TV viewing recommen
S5 EPISODE 15: Murdered While Performing
In Which Murderer’s Episode 15 Season 5 the girls cover people Murdered While Performing. Holly starts you off with the rise and sad early fall of musician Darrell Lance Abbott before Mel goes on to tell you about a very specific kind of performer named Pippa Bakka.Shoutout to Kirsty for another fabulous suggestion - only a few spots are now left in Season 5 so get your theme suggestions in now!There is a very sweet innocent intro from a small child before you are plunged into darkness and death
S5 EPISODE 14: Vegan Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 14 Season 5 the girls cover Vegan Murders. Mel starts off with the story of the short life of Crown Shakur before Holly tells you about another tragically short life, that of Ezra O'Leary.Shoutout Mel’s lash girl Alana for causing Christmas panic, Saraid for the theme suggestion and all our fans who are smashing the Whicher Merch sales!Holly circles the planet earth 4 times trying to get to Mel’s for recording, Mel wins a very special Merch competition and now goes by
S5 EPISODE 13: Social Media Related Murders
ADDITIONAL LISTENER WARNING FOR THIS EPISODE, THERE IS A PARTICULARLY UPSETTING CASE COVERED ABOUT A CHILD IN THIS WEEK’S EPISODE WHICH WE FELT WAS IMPORTANT TO DISCUSS GIVEN THE TOPIC THIS WEEK. LISTENER DISCRETION IS ADVISED. In Which Murderer’s Episode 13 Season 5 the girls talk about Social Media Related Murders. Holly begins this week with the very sad story of Molly McLaren before Mel goes through her disturbing case covering thirteen year old Olly Stephens.Shoutout to Saraid for the theme
S5 EPISODE 12: Murdered by an Ex
In Which Murderer’s Episode 12 Season 5 the girls cover victims who have been Murdered by an Ex. Mel is up first with the case of Ellie Gould (not the singer) followed by Holly with the story of Joseph Oberhansley (hard to say). Shoutout to Saraid for the theme suggestion, we are on a roll with your topics! And yes at some point we will be mixing them up a bit. The girls give you a fascinating glimpse into Scottish weather, Mel has a meltdown about her baby going to highschool while neither Hol
S5 EPISODE 11: Murdered by Police
In Which Murderer’s Episode 11 Season 5 the girls talk about victims who have been Murdered by Police. It’s Holly’s turn to start this week with the bonkers story of NYPD member Charles Becker before Mel goes all sportsy with the case of Dalian Atkinson. Shoutout to Saraid for the theme suggestion, we are on a roll with your topics! And yes at some point we will be mixing them up a bit. Also huge shoutout to Cheryl for coming up with listener nicknames - hello to all our Whichers! (Henry, we wan
S5 EPISODE 10: Car Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 10 Season 5 the girls talk about Car Murders. Mel starts off with the case of Priscilla Ford (no relation probably to the car people) before Holly tells you about Dernell Renauld Stenson the baseball player. Shoutout to Saraid for the theme suggestion, we are on a roll with your topics!Mel is facing reality with a wonderful case of Covid after her wedding and honeymoon, Holly recounts the tragic death of a bird, the girls tell you all about the new Which Murderer MER
S5 EPISODE 9: White Van Man Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 9 Season 5 the girls talk about White Van Man Murders. Holly starts you off with the case of driver James Martin before Mel goes into the tragic story of Matthew Tvrdon.Shoutout to Saraid for the theme suggestion, even though it wasn’t really what you suggested and more what we decided….but you got us there so…..SHOUTOUT. You will learn a great many things about white vans and lizards, Holly is disappointed there is no archery planned at Mel’s wedding, the country of
S5 EPISODE 8: People Framed for Murder
In Which Murderer’s Episode 8 Season 5 the girls talk about People Who Were Framed for Murder. Mel starts off with the case of Robert Spangler before Holly covers the crazy story of Chaskel Werzberger. Shoutout to Cheryl again for the awesome theme suggestion! Also mentioned is listener Kristy who had a mystery box left on her property and ARE YOU OK? Holly pretends to be professional, the girls talk about something actually serious (aside from Murder), the girls will probably never hike the Gra
S5 EPISODE 7: Angel of Death Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 7 Season 5 the girls talk about Angel of Death Murders - which Holly questions literally every nurse she meets about. Holly starts off with the case involving Kimberly Clark Fowler before Mel covers the massive Dr. Shipman story. Shoutout to Cheryl again for the awesome theme suggestion! Also the facebook group members as a whole - we love watching you. In a non creepy way. Holly’s other half also gets a shoutout for actually listening to the girls now. Mel buffers pr
S5 EPISODE 6: CCTV Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 5 Season 6 the girls talk about CCTV Murders - tricky to navigate! Mel starts you off with Hannah Graham before Holly tells you about the case of Sierra LaMar. Shoutout to Cheryl for the awesome theme suggestion! Also Nicole from Virginia for the traumatising fan mail which we adored. The girls talk about the ‘C-Word’ once again, Holly has invented new methods of feeding her pigeons which resulted in a zoo sized bag of bird food being delivered to her flat, Mel has a
S5 EPISODE 5: Divorce Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 5 Season 5 the girls talk about Divorce Murders - tricky to navigate! Holly starts you off with Irene Paterson before Mel tells you about the massive case of Broderick v. Broderick. Shoutout to Natalie for the awesome theme suggestion! Also to our Facebook followers for some hilarious discussions - especially surrounding clowns. The girls talk about drinks and Holly’s Starbucks obsession in a very judgemental way, Mel entertains Holly with her attempts to make sentenc
S5 EPISODE 4: Murder for Survival
In Which Murderer’s Episode 4 Season 5 the girls talk about Murder for Survival cases. Mels starts off with the tragic tale of Valerie Bacot before Holly takes you back in time to the tale of Richard Parker and the code of the seafarers. Shoutouts to Natalie for the awesome theme suggestion and Michelle for the A+ supply of puppy and dog photos. It’s Rosie the dog’s birthday and the girls tell you all about her digestive system (you’re welcome), there is some confusion surrounding goats but the
S5 EPISODE 3: Online Dating Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 3 Season 5 the girls talk about Online Dating Murders. Holly is first (which she forgets) and tells you about the disturbed killer Carl Langdell before Mel tells you all about Khalil Wheeler Weaver - which you absolutely cannot say five times fast.Shoutouts to the mystery review leaver who used a phrase that made the girls research mid-recording and grow at least 2 brain cells. Also to Caitlin for the fabulous suggestion!!!Holly tells you all about her first encounter
S5 EPISODE 2: Bus Driver Murders
In Which Murderer’s Episode 2 Season 5 the girls take a listener suggestion and cover Bus Driver Murders. Mel starts you off with the story of Darren Vickers before Holly tells you about Keith Bettison.Shoutouts to Jim who suggested this week’s topic and took Holly’s flagrant competitive challenging with grace (turns out she is not the F1 driver she thought), Cheryl for some good sleep advice and Carrie for telling Mel she said a super challenging medical word correctly. A special shoutout to Kr
S5 EPISODE 1: Murders Solved by Dogs
The first episode of Season 5 brings you Murders Solved by Dogs! Holly kicks things off with the story of Shantay Leann Leyba-Huntington before Mel tells you about Duane Daniels who had quite the racket going in London. Shoutouts to Kristy who suggested this topic (which was loved by the girls!) and Natalie for epic memeing. This episode brings you more pathetic maths, Holly explains the perils of dash cams and dying while singing Disney tunes, apologies are made to Miami (Welcome to Miami) by m
S4 EPISODE 52: European Murders Season Finale
In Season 4 Episode 52, the final episode of Season 4, the girls talk about European Murders. Mel kicks this special episode off with her case covering Ivan Kulesh before Holly tells you about Joachim Kroll.Shoutouts to Kirsty and Millie the Cat who submitted a great theme suggestion! The end of Mel’s first season brings you a very determined Mel still holding on tight to her Strictly Come Dancing dreams, Holly being dead inside and emotionless about the end of the season, Mel potentially becomi
S4 EPISODE 51: City Murders
In Season 4 Episode 51, the penultimate Season 4 episode, the girls talk about City Murders following on from last week’s Countryside Murder theme. Chester, UK and New York, USA! Holly starts us off with the insane story of Sadie Catherine Cook before Mel tells you about the famous case of Kitty Genovese.Shoutouts for Cheryl and Bailey!The girls are recording in Mel’s bedroom which Holly finds creepy, Holly is dreading Mel’s driving on the way to the HEN WEEKEND, the girls determine they need to
S4 EPISODE 50: Countryside Murders
In Season 4 Episode 50 the girls talk about Countryside Murders due to Mel living in the middle of nowhere. Mel starts things off with the story of Michael Stone before Holly tells you about a supernatural countryside case involving Charles Walton. Shoutouts near the end for some super fans!Mel shakes things up with her intro, the girls are still too tired to pass as humans, Holly’s theories about animals having meetings is proven correct, a horrible crime takes place where Holly used to live, t
S4 EPISODE 49: Honeymoon Murders
In Season 4 Episode 49 the girls talk about Honeymoon Murders courtesy of the soon to be honeymooning Mel. Holly kicks things off with a very sad story about Welsh couple Ben & Catherine Mullany before Mel tells you about Scott Robin Rolston.Shoutouts to Kirsty (and Kristy of course) for a podcast recommendation and topic suggestion and Cheryl for the great laughs. Holly starts off by dying from not sleeping to which Mel quickly follows with her own fatigue, the English language is challenged in
S4 EPISODE 48: Hospital Murders
In Season 4 Episode 48 the girls cover cases of Hospital Murders which is a pretty terrifying thought! Even for them. Mel starts you off with the case of a very busy man named Charles Cullen before Holly tells you the French tale of Romain Dupuy.Shoutout to Kirsty (and by default Kristy) for this week’s theme suggestion as well as Cheryl and Kenda. This episode is full of pigeon apologies, detective puppies (with a legend of a Homicide Hunter shoutout), a firm rule that no tummies should be in t
S4 EPISODE 47: Murdered on a Night Out
In Season 4 Episode 47 the girls cover cases of Murder on a Night Out. Holly tells you the sad tale of a young woman named Jennifer Moore before Mel chats through the strange case of Lorraine Cox. Shoutout to Mel - by Mel - for her own suggestion. The girls start off teaching you about light before Holly lays down a highly scrutinised earth sciences fact complete with hand gestures, Mel laments her lack of interest in school, Holly fills you in on an Edinburgh icon she is emotionally invested i
S4 EPISODE 46: Kidnapped & Murdered
In Season 4 Episode 46 the girls cover cases of Kidnap and Murder. Mel starts us off this week with the infamous and tragic story of Polly Klaas before Holly tells you about a murderer who inspired on of the greatest thrillers of all times - Gary Heidnik. Shoutout to Michelle for the topic suggestion and adorable puppy photos! Mel comes to you in her professional podcasting onesie with added distracting pom-poms, Holly fills you in on her new hobby which of course includes animals, Mel flat out
S4 EPISODE 45: Lockdown Murders
In Season 4 Episode 45 the girls talk about Lockdown Murders. Holly starts you off with the sad case of Kelly Fitzgibbons before Mel tells you about the story of Penelope Jackson and her rather unapologetic murder story. Shoutout to Caitlin for another great suggestion, Terry for the great feedback and the country of Kenya. Technical difficulties plague the girls from the start, Mel gets a happy surprise field trip, gun safety issues set off a small Melnado, the audacity of Mel’s murderer gives
S4 EPISODE 44: Solved Cold Cases
In Season 4 Episode 44 the girls talk about Solved Cold Case Murders. Mel starts you off with the difficult to research story of Sara Lynn Wineski before Holly tells you about the murder of Krystal Beslanowitch.Shoutout to Jordan for another great suggestion - we did them all! The girls provide you with a comprehensive review of the Scottish Midge phenomenon - 0/10 do not recommend - before Holly offends Mel. With good cause. Geography strikes again and ruins Mels life, conclusions bring back th
S4 EPISODE 43: Murdered by Poison
In Season 4 Episode 43 the girls talk about victims who were Murdered by Poison. Holly starts you off with a very tragic story about a little boy named Garnett-Paul Thompson Spears before Mel turns things around with an actual real life super villain named Graham Young. Shoutout to Jordan for another great suggestion and the amazing double act that is Kirsty and Kristy. The month of April is discussed with very different focus points for the girls, Mel reveals her dream date, you will witness Ho
S4 Episode 42: Murder Involving the Elderly
In Season 4 Episode 42 the girls talk about Murder Involving the Elderly. Mel kicks things off with the stuff-of-nightmares case of Leonarda Cianciulli before Holly tells you about the soon to be saint Jacques Hamel. Shoutout to Jordan for another great suggestion and Michelle for her adorable puppy baby photos. Mel gifts you with body air while managing to live with less teeth, she is also shocked by the Scottish rain in Scotland as a Scottish person, Holly is following squirrels to her apparen
S4 EPISODE 41: Murders Solved Online
In Season 4 Episode 41 the girls cover Murders Solved Online via those incredible people we call Web Slueths. Holly tells the sad rags to riches story of Abraham Lee Shakespeare before Mel talks about Greg May.Shoutout to Jordan for another great suggestion, Mark for always giving us encouragement and glamorous Emma for sharing the podcast and keeping Mel sparkly. Buckle up for this episode….it’s a gong show. The girls are rather flippant about the WW3 situation, Holly needs a place to stay in R
S4 EPISODE 40: Murder Involving Animals
In Season 4 Episode 40 the girls cover a very sad topic (yes sadder than murder) and tell you about some murder cases involving animals. Mels starts things off with the massive case of BTK before Holly almost follows the theme with Clive Sharp's crimes. Shoutout to Saraid for another great suggestion! You will learn all about Holly’s teeny tiny appliance woes, Mel’s wordle woes - she is not amused with America by the way, there is a tv show suggestion which Holly can’t remember but swears is ama
S4 EPISODE 39: Wedding Murders
In Season 4 Episode 39 the girls take a hilarious (in an ironic way) topic suggestion from Mel’s soon to be mother-in-law and cover Wedding Murders. Holly starts us off with a gem of a character named Scott Samson before Mel tells you about another winner named Arthur Hutchinson (who may or may not be dead). Shoutout to Jenny for this amazing suggestion and also to Michelle for her puppy photos. Please keep the animal photos coming!Mel gets in quick this week with telling you who we are given Ho
S4 EPISODE 38: Exercise and Murder
In Season 4 Episode 38 the girls cover murders connected to Exercise - double terrible if you ask Holly. Mel tells us all about Ahmaud Arbery before Holly chats through the case of Daniel Lugo. Shoutout to Robyn for the theme suggestion and for sticking with us! Be like Robyn - send us suggestions!The girls discuss Holly’s birthday gifting (food related), the general breakdown of their bodies, they debate jogging routes that involve running through houses, Holly stretches the theme yet again and
S4 EPISODE 37: Retail Murders
In Season 4 Episode 37 the girls cover some well known Retail Murders - which is ironic because retail in general is Murder. Holly kicks us off with the Lululemon Murder before Mel dips into the HiFi Murders from the 70s. Shoutouts to Kirsty (not Kristy) for the suggestion and also to Jordan who came to us via a recommendation from beloved LouLou. Beds are the topic of the day leading to snuggle chat, Mel is under the impression she is mellowing, Holly has an excessive amount of Lululemon clothi
S4 EPISODE 36: Murders Solved by Psychics
In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle. Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job. Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains on a health not-kick, we learn that Holly skates like a sailboat, Mel tells us about her love for
S4 EPISODE 35: Hatecrime Murders
In Season 4 Episode 35 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Hatecrime Murders. Holly starts with the sad story of Nikki Kuhnhausen before Mel tells you about the horrific murder of Matthew Shepard.Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Also Caitlin who is a quickly rising superfan and Natalie who Holly is ‘real life many years’ friends with but has no recollection of HOW they became friends. Holly talks about her neverending flood curse, Mel talks about her nev
S4 EPISODE 34 Hybristophilia
In Season 4 Episode 34 the girls talk about Hybristophilia suggested by a listener. (n. sexual interest in and attraction to those who commit crimes. In some cases, this may be directed toward people in prison for various types of criminal activities.) They didn’t know what it meant either. Mel kicks it off with the story of the killer Canadian Paul Bernardo before Holly tells you about a Hillside Strangler. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Hope all is well in the middle of nowhere. Mel t
S4 EPISODE 33: Family Cover Ups
In Season 4 Episode 33 the girls talk about Families Who Cover Up Murder - which they would absolutely not do for their families. Holly starts you off with the case of Patricia O’Connor before Mel goes over the infamous Robert Durst (The Jinx) story. Shoutout to Carrie who tuned in on Christmas Eve while wrapping presents last year. Good job on those corners girl!Holly believes she has finally matured as she has full bladder control 75% of the time now, Mel has reached the age of hand cream gift
S4 EPISODE 32: Brits Murdered Abroad
In Season 4 Episode 32 the girls talk about Brits Murdered Abroad which was suggested by fiance Dave. Mel jumps into things with the story of Lucie Blackman before Holly tells you about Joanna Parrish. Shoutouts to Kirsty and Kristy - WE ARE CONSTANTLY CONFUSED BY YOUR NAMES and Michelle - there were pet sharing photos and Holly was blissed out for days. Mel struggles with her English due to her storing alcohol in her left cheek since December, Holly gets someone in trouble accidentally, Mel is
S4 EPISODE 31 Trusted Professions
In Season 4 Episode 31 the girls take a listener suggestion from VIP future mother-in-law Jenny and cover Trusted Profession Murders. Holly kicks us off with the case of Andrew Lindo before Mel goes into the recent and controversial story of Wayne Couzens. Shoutouts to Ansley and Rosanny from the distant land of Instagram!The girls are recording for the first time since last year and have declared themselves fat, sad and skint. Mel once again manages to offend an entire profession, Holly has mul
S4 Episode 30: Missionaries and Murder
In Season 4 Episode 30 the girls take not only a listener suggestion, but a listener’s case! Mel tells you about Graham Staines before Holly covers the story of Werner Groenewald. Both are terribly tragic. Shoutout to Michelle for allowing us to tell her family’s story. Welcome to the first podcast episode of 2022 where we find out just how literal Mel is, Holly apparently now lives off the land, the girls don’t need to debate this case very long although they do manage to talk about other thing
S4 Episode 29: New Years Murders
In Season 4 Episode 29 the girls wish you a very happy 2022 with MURDER. New Years Murders to be exact. Holly talks about murderer Scott Watson before Mel tells you all about John Allen Mohammad.The girls continue with the Covid chat which annoys them both, they touch their microphones a lot in this episode so…. good luck listeners, the girls tell you how much they hate New Years Eve but also have a great New Years Eve everyone, Holly chooses a challenging case in regards to the entire premise o
S4 Episode 28: Christmas Murders
In Season 4 Episode 28 the girls talk about Christmas Murders! Merry festive homicides all ‘round. Mel begins this seasonal episode with the murder of Sameena Imam before Holly tells you about a local Edinburgh Scotland case involving Melissa Young. Shoutouts to Cheryl who made some drinky suggestions and Kirsty who had a tragic death in her family related to one of our topics. We find out Holly is in Christmas limbo and moving hell, Mel is festive and prepared which is highly suspicious given
S4 Episode 27: Politicians & Murder
In Season 4 Episode 27 the girls talk about Policiticians and Murder. Holly starts off with an old case about Thomas Ley before Mel tells the heartbreaking story of Helen Joanne Cox. This week the podcast tackles the important topic of napping, 'drunk friend Ang' is spoken of, the audacity of dead men infuriates the girls, a traditional name is revealed to be actually quite nice while also being very difficult to say (apologies to an entire faith are made), the girls are super bummed about Mels
S4 Episode 26: Crocodile Tears
In Season 4 Episode 26 the girls talk about Crocodile Tears murderers who were terrible actors. Mel talks about the disgusting Philpotts before Holly tells you about poor Carole Heslop (Wardell). Shoutout to listener Michelle who suggested this week’s theme!Holly discusses Mel’s bathing habits, the girls reveal their weekend away shenanigans for next year, there are some predictable struggles with names, Mel plans out Holly’s gravestone, Holly will totally be haunting people and there is a leng
S4 Episode 25: Murdered on Set
In Season 4 Episode 25 the girls cover a hot topic at the moment – Murdered on Set. Holly talks about Paul Michael Kelly who had one million siblings before Mel tells you all about Sarah JonesShout-outs to Michelle from Dougliehill Dog Boarding Kennels in the West of Scotland who found us on multiple platforms for some theme suggesters (which we have totally used!), Mel’s middle of nowhere pal Saraid (who is a very brave jogger) and a massive shoutout to Jenny – big fan of your kids! And your su
S4 Episode 24: Dentists Who Murder
In Season 4 Episode 24 the girls talk about Dentists Who Murder - perfectly timed to be just before Mel’s dental appointment. Mel chats about Colin Howell before Holly tells you about Tony Protopappas. Shoutouts to listeners Mark and Robyn! KEEP SENDING YOUR TOPIC SUGGESTIONS. We are lazy. There are more updates on how dark it is in Scotland, dental traumas are revisited, Mel forgets major surgery that she had and the girls would like to point out that not all dentists are bad dentists….but the
S4 Episode 23: Swamp Murders
In Season 4 Episode 23 the girls talk about Swamp Murders. Holly starts with the not really Swampy tale of Gracious David West before Mel tells you all about Kathy Bonney. Who was Swampy.Holly has more pandemic theories, Mel gets in trouble for finding out the obvious, math continues it’s evil presence, Mel offers up her bed to Holly and the girls give you very helpful weather and darkness updates. Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who recently placed a large order for
S4 Episode 22; Beach Murders
In Season 4 Episode 22 the girls talk about Murders on the Beach. Mels starts things off with the case of the 2015 hotel attack in Tunisia before Holly covers the story of the Jenner Beach Murders. Holly is wandering the United Kingdom while Mel is wandering the woods, Mel is surprised that Africa was hot in the summer, Holly loses her English, LSD is declared not good, there is some wedding talk and debate over how Holly will be killed. Production, recording and postproduction completed by Holl
S4 Episode 21: Religious Murders
In Season 4 Episode 21 the girls talk about Religious Murders. Holly starts with the story of Hans Schmidt who was a very confusing person and then Mel tells you all about Ervil Morrell LeBaron.Shoutouts to Michelle and Robyn! Holly argues the breed of Rosie the dog with Mel - her actual owner, Holly considers getting ordained for Mel’s wedding, there is some impressive Sherlocking for oldy times, Mel’s case seriously tests her vocabulary, there are far too many wives and the girls remind you th
S4 Episode 20: Stalkers Who Murder
In Season 4 Episode 20 the girls take a listener suggestion and cover Stalkers Who Murder as a topic repeat. Mels starts off with Amie Harwick before Holly tells you the enraging story of Shiori Ino. Shoutouts to listeners Cheryl for her suggestions and Jim for his recommendation! HELP FOR STALKINGhttps://www.gov.uk/report-stalker - UKhttps://paladinservice.co.uk/ - UKhttps://www.justice.gov/ovw/stalking - USAhttps://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/health-promotion/stop-family-violence/p
S4 Episode 19: Mels Greatest Fear Burning to Death
In Season 4 Episode 19 the girls talk about Mel’s Greatest Fear which is Burning to Death. Holly starts us off with the horrific tale of Jessica Lane Chambers and Mels then covers the story of Gagandip Singh. Mel is fading fast in this episode due to the Covid and Holly is fading due to just having to be an adult, the girls slip into a fashion segment, Holly is offended by Mel - again, the girls are annoyed by a jury, the girls have a very delayed second segment, Holly totally makes up laws that
S4 Episode 18: Couples Who Murder Part Two
In Season 4 Episode 18 Part Two - that’s right another two parter! - the girls talk about Couples Who Murder (together, not each other). Mel spoke about The Moors Murders - Ian Brady and Myra Hindley last week and this week Holly covers Cynthia Coffman and James Marlow.Mel struggles with up and across directions, the girls are confused by the affordability of multiple divorces, some amazing life choices take place in Holly’s story, Mel is outed as one of the annoying month counters, Mel has a li
S4 Episode 18: Couples Who Murder Part One
In Season 4 Episode 18 Part One - that’s right another two parter! - the girls talk about Couples Who Murder (together, not each other) and Mel takes this weeks episode on with a the heavy hitting story of The Moors Murders - Ian Brady and Myra Hindley.Mel thinks her inability to speak and function are all down to COVID (Holly is withholding her opinion), the girls appreciate the listeners doing their jobs for them, one of Mel’s murderers also murdered the image of Marilyn Monroe, Holly is convi
S4 Episode 17: Murdering the Boss
In Season 4 Episode 17 the girls talk about Murdering the Boss – we fully understand that sometimes this may be tempting but please don’t be one of our episodes. Holly starts with a fellow British Columbian named Eric Allen Kirkpatrick before Mel tells you all about murderer Yolanda Saldívar.Shoutout for Superfan Carrie and thanks so much for your amazing suggestions….if it was in fact you who did suggest the theme….we are super great with details thanks for asking. The old ladies discuss how i
S4 Episode 16: Mels & Murder
In Season 4 Episode 16 the girls talk about Melanies and Murder – our particular Melanie is excluded from this of course (for now). Mel kicks things off with the story of Melanie McGuire before Holly tells you the sad story of Melanie Ann Road. Shoutout for Superfan Carrie and thanks so much for your amazing suggestions….keep 'em coming!Mel contracts the Corona, Holly gives an update on the Murder Flat, Mel’s Melanie is a smart lady but the dumbest criminal ever made, Mel appears surprised Holly
S4 Episode 15: Courthouse Murders
In Season 4 Episode 15 the girls talk about Murders that happened in Courtrooms – aka Courthouse Murders. Holly kicks it off with Tahir Naseem and Mel follows with Brian Nichols who we are not a fan of. There is a very informative cereal knowledge session which includes singing, Holly finally writes down her sources, Mel is very encouraging of some crimes possibly, the girls are finally aware of how much they are talking and stick to the half hour slot (totally unintentionally of course) and the
S4 Episode 14: Music Made me Do It
In Season 4 Episode 14 the girls talk about Murderers Who Were Inspired by Music. Mel kicks it off with the Columbine High School Shooting before Holly covers the story of Jared Lee Loughner.Mel tea shames Holly but also doesn’t know what year it is so maybe don’t listen to her too much, we find out that Holly doesn’t make her own tea ever, a recap of girls night reveals a severe difference in musical tastes, Mel tries hard to get Calvin Harris to take notice (sorry Calvin) of the podcast, Holly
S4 Episode 13: Incels Who Kill
In Season 4 Episode 13 the girls cover a suggested topic from Season 1-3 Co-host Gemma – Incels Who Murder. AKA Involuntary Celibates. Holly starts things off with the poster boy for this group who was responsible for the 2014 Isla Vista murders before Mel chats through the case of Alek Minassian. Shout-out to Carrie for her lovely comments about Mel who is doing much better at checking Facebook occasionally. The girls are up against a big deadline, Holly tries to describe World of Warcraft and
S4 Episode 12: Olympic Murders
In Season 4 Episode 12 the girls cover Olympic Murders with Mel starting things off with the Dave Shultz tragedy before Holly covers the Munich Massacre. Shout-outs to lovely bestie Loulou and our Gemma. Also high fives to Melinda for suggesting this weeks theme. Holly is all over the place with food and time, Mel tries to get the listeners arrested and fired, evil geese fight for their lives, Holly has an unreasonable dislike for poor Mark Ruffalo, a wild pooper is spotted in the city, Mel has
S4 Episode 11: Revenge Murders
In Season 4 Episode 11 the girls cover tales of Murder and Revenge! Mels starts us off with the story of Connie Serbu before Holly tells the sad tale of the Ding family. Things start off terribly with Holly drinking while recording, Mel is outed as a drink sniffer, Holly has a police connection and a burning body story, the girls have an actual fight over funding each other going on the run and we all learn what sport will kill you – if you play it with Holly. Production, recording and postprodu
S4 Epiode 10: Clowns and Circus Murders
In Season 4 Episode 10 the girls talk about Clowns and Circus Murders…which are extra terrible because CLOWNS. Mel starts off with a true crime Goliath…..John Wayne Gacy before Holly leaves you with the slightly less horrific but still murdery tale of Eva Clark.Shoutouts to Melinda (who superfanned a theme suggestion our way – which we are absolutely using) and Lindy who revealed there is a Which Murderer team member on Love Island. Probably.Holly reveals how she traumatises Mel with her messagi
S4 Episode 9: Genocide
In Season 4 Episode 9 the girls tackle the horrific topic of Genocide. While we figure if you are listening to a murder podcast you are pretty Teflon, we do include a bit of warning with this one due to the brutal level of violence spoken about. Holly kicks it off with the Killing Fields of Cambodia before Mel talks about the Armenian Genocide. The girls discuss the Dead Body Window and Holly’s DNA, farming is hard, the Kardashians make an odd appearance, smart people don’t do well under dictato
S4 Episode 8: Athletes Who Murder
In Season 4 Episode 8 the girls talk about Athletes Who Murder. Mel starts off with Robert Rozier who was the Mr. Bean of Murder before Holly tells you about Mark Anthony with a truly tragic nickname. Holly is hungry and leaking, Mel loves the sports theme but regrets it when she has to actually communicate with Holly about the sports, the girls judge cults pretty harshly, fences are the natural enemies of footballers and the girls figure out their one common agreement point. Production, recordi
S4 Episode 7: Arsonists Who Murder
In Season 4 Episode 7 the girls talk about Arsonists Who Commit Murder. Holly kicks things off with the very first namey Bruce George Peter Lee before Mel tells you all about John Leonard Orr.Shoutouts for Facebook fans Sarah and Mel’s new friend Dave. You are both now legally required to suggest topics. Mel’s singing talents are showcased, bouncy castles are a very important topic requiring actual research, Holly almost dies before recording because of her hair, the dark ages of information are
S4 Episode 6: Fast Food Murders
In Season 4 Episode 6 the girls talk about Fast Food Murders. Mel covers the story of Evan Ebel before Holly tells you how badly wrong Paul Dennis Reid turned out. Holly died 5 times from the heat during this episode, Mel tip-toes around the topic of football, there is some confusion about whether some people can play golf after death, Holly makes up facts yet again and the brain has been renamed as ‘doodads in the front of your head’. You’re welcome. Production, recording and post production co
S4 Episode 5: Conartists Who Murder
In Season 4 Episode 5 the girls talk about Con Artists Who Murder. Holly kicks it off with the case of Carol Waugh before Mel tells you about Sante and Kenny, a super healthy mother and son duo.Shoutouts to Mark on Facebook, Superfan Caitriona (whose last name we will never say out loud), Dave on Insta and Cara who Holly annoyed with her sweeping incorrect generalisations – sorry Cara! And the country of South Africa. And the continent of Africa. It’s still hot in Scotland and Holly lets everyon
S4 Episode 4: Lawyers Who Are Murdered
In Season 4 Episode 4 the girls talk about Lawyers Who Were Murdered. Mel kicks it off with the case of Sarah H. Quirt Sann before Holly tells you about Rashid Rehman in Pakistan.Holly is stripping off in the corner of Mel’s recording loft, Mel is the only one who actually remembers to tell you who they are, gun laws are once again questioned in America, Holly’s voice is sad but she is not, there is a big debate at the end and Mel actually uses the word ‘groovy’ in a real life sentence. You also
S4 Episode 3: Abductors Who Murder
In Season 4 Episode 3 the girls tell you all about Abductors Who Murder. Holly teaches you about Donald ‘Nappey’ Neilson who was not a fan of diapers or postal workers before Mel covers Anni Dewani’s murder right after Holly awkwardly snickers at the name. Shoutouts to Facebook Sarah (are you still listening?) and a weird one to the wonderful Gemma and Consulting Producer Craig. We find out Holly is finally back to work and sad that she can no longer nap, you are all introduced to the best girl
S4 Episode 2B: Journalists Who Are Murdered
In Season 4 Episode 2 (Part Two) the girls finish talking about Journalists Who Are Murdered. Holly covers the twisty tale of Jake Lingle then there is a detailed debate. Mel kicks it all off by insulting an entire nation, Holly continues the mob theme from episode one despite hating mob murders, there is a big debate despite the method of murder being exactly the same in both cases, there is a discussion on all the mistakes in Hollys life and the girls are entering their seven year itch. Produ
S4 Episode 2A Journalists Who Are Murdered
In Season 4 Episode 2 (Part One) the girls talk about Journalists Who Are Murdered. Mel covers the sad story of Jill Dando in the first of this two part episode. Mel emphasises the best way to keep Holly happy, the girls decide gynaecologists are undatable, Mel makes a royal comparison, and Holly has to badly sum up this episode post-recording due to her being an idiot. EVERYTHING IS FINE. Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who despite thorough training from Consulting
Season 4 Episode 1 Mob Murders
Welcome to Season 4 of Which Murderer!In Season 4 Episode 1 Mel and Holly cover Mob Murders - Mel's choice as Holly has terrible taste in TV shows. It all connects. Holly kicks off the episode with the story of Albert Anastasia before Mel tells you about Abe Reles.The girls discuss Holly's terrible brain, some new possible career options, an overview of Mel's extensive criminal history, there are some absolutely fabulous names and crazy case connections made between the two murderers. Production
Season 4 Introduction
Welcome to Season 4 of Which Murderer!In the Season 4 Intro you finally get to meet this season’s new co-host – MEL! You’ll hear how she started off on this journey hating true crime and podcasts….look how that turned out. Almost as well as Holly saying she would never date again. There are loads of great cases lined up for this season so stay tuned! Production, recording and postproduction completed by Holly who is trying to convince Consulting Producer Craig to be on permanent Facetime. Holl
S3 EPISODE 52: Diagnosed Psychopath Murders
In the Season 3 Final Episode the girls cover Diagnosed Psychopaths Who Murder for Gemma’s final podcast appearance. Gemma chats through Robert Black before Holly talks about Jane Toppin.Holly has some nickname confusion, Gemma tells a horror story of note, Holly may be serving seconds when it comes to her murderer and the girls share a final tough choice at the end of this episode.Much love to Gemma and Producer Craig ss they start their next big project in life, we wish them all the very best
S3 EPISODE 51: Beauty Pageant Murders
In Season 3 Episode 51 the girls talk about Beauty Pageant Murders with Holly kicking off her story of Svetlana Kotova before Gemma dives into her tale about Michaela McAreavey.Shoutouts for Sarah with a case suggestion and Woody over at Real Life Real Crime who helped solve a cold case murder recently. We are super impressed and proud and totally recommend you listen to him. And not just because of his melty voice.Time travel breaks Holly once again, the girls have a moment over Gemma’s second
S3 EPISODE 50: Cabin in the Woods Murders
In Season 3 Episode 50 the girls cover Cabin in the Woods Murders with Gemma telling you all about the murder of David and Estelle Akeman before Holly chats through the nightmare of the Tiede family. BIG PODCAST ANNOUNCEMENT FOR SEASON 4The girls reveal some dirty secrets, Producer Craig loses his sweet little mind, Holly is outraged by Producer Craig’s opinions on cats, random adoptions might be a new trend and the girls ask you to make the public uncomfortable. Production, recording and postpr
S3 EPISODE 49: Murderers Who Have Disappeared
In Season 3 Episode 49 the girls talk about Murderers Who Have Disappeared with Holly covering the Santa Rosa Hitchhiker Murders before Gemma talks about the French case of Xavier Pierre Marie Dupont de Ligonnès.Holly comes clean about cheating on her diet plan, Producer Craig turns evil in the sunshine, eyebrow communication remains unreliable, California was not a great place to be in the 70s, studying chipmunks is a thing, the girls make Producer Craig figure out what Lyme is for other than m
S3 EPISODE 48: College Murders
In Season 3 Episode 48 the girls talk about College Murders with Gemma kicking the episode off with the story of Tina Morris. Holly then jumps into the surprising case of Robert Bechtel. Shoutouts for Helen and Catriona from the Superfan Gallery who were both a bit traumatised by the Manchester episode. The girls clarify that you cannot in fact take your mommy to college, Holly has an oddly uplifting approach to things, Gemma tells Producer Craig he’s not doing enough with his life and there are
S3 EPISODE 47: Surviving Serial Killers
In Season 3 Episode 47 the girls talk about Surviving Serial Killers with Holly giving a very basic covering of Richard Specks attempted murder of Corazon Amurao before Gemma dives into the case of Kate Moir surviving the killer couple David and Catherine Bernie. It’s cold and spooky in Scotland during this recording and there is bitterness, having 8 kids leads to heart attack, someone actually has a worse relationship history than Holly and this week turns out to be a tricky choice. Production,
S3 EPISODE 46: Prom Murders
In Season 3 Episode 46 the girls cover Prom Night Murders with Gemma kicking it off talking about Paul Michael Crowder before Holly chats through the tale of Adam James Sapikowski.The girls win their own professional standards contest, Producer Craig gets yelled at, shot cows are involved in one of the murders and the girls request a bit of a delay on shooting them in the head as a general PSA. Production, recording and postproduction completed by Producer Craig who as the official looker upper
S3 EPISODE 45: Wartime Murders
In Season 3 Episode 45 the girls talk about Wartime Murders. Holly kicks it off with the story of Paul Orgorzow before Gemma tells you about Harry Dobkin.Shoutout for Lindy who shared her panther cat Willow on the Facebook Page – SHARE ALL YOUR ANIMALS ALL THE TIME. Farming leads to Nazi’s, Holly lectures you all on the Spanish Flu and propaganda, apparently you can be ‘too bad’ to be a Nazi, Gemma tells you about the shortest marriage and fastest conception in world history (not a science fact)
S3 EPISODE 44: Murderers Haunted by Victims Ghosts
In Season 3 Episode 44 the girls talk about Murderers Haunted by Victim’s Ghosts. Gemma starts you off with the case of Adrian Daou before Holly goes over Jose Ferreira’s story. Shoutout for Scott who is smitten with Producer Craig apparently. The girls are trying not to let Craig hear his praise or he will take over and kick them out of the team. The girls are engrossing you all with endless stories of Wotsits, Holly weighs in on Gemma’s case and comes down on Canada, both girls struggle with n
S3 EPISODE 43: Manchester Murders
In Season 3 Episode 43 the girls talk about Manchester Murders following the case suggestion by listener Ray. Holly starts off with the disturbing case of Suzanne Capper before Gemma tells the story of ‘The Beast of Manchester’. Shoutouts for Jennifer Fabulous who understands an abbreviation and Postie Jess from down under whose ears must be bleeding by now. Thanks for the five star review! BE LIKE JESS. The girls are stunned by their own professionalism, Holly is devastated by Gemma’s opinion o
S3 EPISODE 42: Murders Inspired by TV Shows
In Season 3 Episode 42 the girls talk about Murderers Influenced by TV Shows which was a re-record due to Holly being Holly. Luckily neither one of them has any reliable memory. Holly kicks it off with murderer Mark Twitchell, a fellow Canadian unfortunately before Gemma tells us about Joseph Hall who the girls have strong opinions about. Shoutouts for Ray who contacted us with a case suggestion and Rachel who ABANDONED Scotland for the land of Canada. Holly struggles with cosplay examples, Gem
S3 EPISODE 41: Siblings Who Murder
In Season 3 Episode 41 the girls talk about Siblings Who Murder. Gemma kicks things off with the case of the Scissor Sisters Linda and Charlotte Mulhall then Holly chats through the story of twins Betty and Peggy Woods. Penis removal takes place, sympathy is hard to muster in the first case, AA meetings were the first Tinder (apparently), 2020 makes another scary appearance and there is a surprise tie breaker appearance by Producer Craig. Who still does not have a voice. Production, recording an
S3 EPISODE 40: Chainsaw Murders
In Season 3 Episode 40 the girls talk about Chainsaw Murders – happens more than you’d think. Gemma starts you off with the gruesome murderer Jonathan Stasiuk before Holly tells you all about the sad story of Teri Lea Zenner and her brutal murder. Shoutouts for the fabulous band @Battalionofflies who are dropping their EP TODAY so go check them out, Dave who recommended us (including a minor dig at the Canadian co-host – watching you Dave, watching you) and Super Fan Natalie whose children have
S3 EPISODE 39: Murderers Who Communicated with Police & Press
In Season 3 Episode 39 the girls talk about Murderers Who Communicated with Police & Press. Holly starts us off with the Lipstick Killer and Gemma then goes over the Smiley Face Killer. Holly tells tales of murder in the local zoo, Scottish weather is the worst, Gemmas insults Holly RIGHT BEFORE HER BIRTHDAY about her age, we all learn Holly has tried to get her fist in her mouth and Gemma has a pretty severe apple injury. Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who
S3 EPISODE 38: Ax Murders
In Season 3 Episode 38 the girls talk about Ax Murders – can you believe it’s taken 3 seasons to get here? – with Gemma kicking it off by telling us the tale of the Ax Man of New Orleans and Holly then going on to chat us through the South African murderer Henri Van Breda.Shoutout for Superfan Mel who is having a very busy apocalypse. A translator is brought in for Holly’s case but she totally ignores it and changes the first name pronunciation repeatedly throughout the story….as per usual, the
S3 EPISODE 37: Cruise Ship Murders
In Season 3 Episode 37 the girls talk about Cruise Ship Murders suggested by listener Jared Muppet (thanks JM!!!). Holly tells us about Tamara Tucker then Gemma covers the death of Kristy Manzanares.Shoutout for Sarah from the Facebook page/group.The girls become a TV Guide…you’re welcome, a scene from Titanic is reenacted (obvious reasons but also completely by accident), fines for Murder are introduced by the girls and cruise ships will not cancel holidays for your death. Just in case you were
S3 EPISODE 36: Bodies in Wells
In Season 3 Episode 36 the girls talk about murders which involved Bodies in Wells suggested by all three of Holly’s personalities. Gemma kicks things off with the story of Jessie McMahon who waited a long time to be found and Holly goes over the murder of David King.Shoutouts for Helen, Dave, Kev – much love to you all!Holly is missing Craigs hand-feeding methods, the girls give themselves bonus points for remembering their own episode, Gemma thinks babies drive forklifts, the French police pro
S3 EPISODE 35: Tinder Murders
In Season 3 Episode 35 the girls talk about Tinder Murders – which does not help Holly’s reluctance to rejoin. Holly starts off with the sad tale of Grace Millane who died on her birthday, then Gemma talks about Sidney Loofe. Shoutouts for Jomya1989 who left a lovely iTunes review, Kyla on the Facebook page and Superfan Caitriona. The girls give their Christmas reviews (and a life update from Holly – send chocolate), science proves once again that pissed off or curious women make the best online
S3 EPISODE 34: Rich People Who Murder
In Season 3 Episode 34 the girls cover the interesting field of Rich People Who Murder. Gemma starts off with the story of Michael Skakel which has an unexpected legal ending and Holly tells us about the strange John du Pont murder case. A missed shout-out eventually happens for Kate despite Holly being unprepared for life and podcasting, then there is a secret cryptic message that we aren’t talking about but do a secret shout-out anyway….Gemma has some deep cleaning plans, Holly is having a no-
S3 EPISODE 33: Murders on Airplanes
In Season 3 Episode 33 the girls start 2021 off with a Murders on Airplanes theme….which does nothing to help with Holly's fear of flying. Holly starts off with murderer Yuji Nishizawa (‘All Nippon Airways’ Flight 61) who was very safety conscious and Gemma follows up with the scary story of Andreas Lubitz and Germanwings Flight 9525.Future Gemma and Holly were hoping for some good vibes – week one of 2021 pretty much took care of those, Hollys focused murderer really did try to save lives as we
S3 EPISODE 32: New Years Murders
In Season 3 Episode 32 the girls wish you a calm and JUMANJI FREE 2021 with New Year’s Murder themed stories. Gemma starts off with the sad murder Brandon Teena and Holly tells us all about murderer Rhys HancockShoutouts to fans Dave, Natalie and Helen…. thanks so much for listening and chatting to us. While it’s mentioned Holly is dating someone in this episode she is in fact not anymore…. awkward…. carry on as normal….Gemma is very punchy and a bit feisty, math pops up again and the girls stru
S3 EPISODE 31: Egyptian Murders
In Season 3 Episode 31 the girls cover some Egyptian Murders in recognition of the popularity of the podcast in the Egyptian iTunes charts. Holly tells you all about Raya and Sakina’s money making murder plans and Gemma chats through the story of Ramadan Abdel Rehim Mansour. Holly is still being attacked by Nandos and now has a Starbucks issue, Gemma’s story is super sad…like her energy levels during this episode and the conclusion is a pretty easy this week. Due to Gemma’s horrific picking. Pr
S3 EPISODE 30: Rap Murders
In Season 3 Episode 30 the girls speak about Rap Murders which is kind of thanks to a fan named Steven and Producer Craig’s unique brain interpretations. Gemma talks about the aptly named rapper C-Murder and Holly goes through the story of Mac Minister. Holly is attacked by Nandos, Gemma goes over a small mistake from a previous episode (small in that we said the opposite of the truth) and Snoop Dogg makes a few appearances.Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig wh
S3 EPISODE 29: Murders with Weird Backstories
In Season 3 Episode 29 the girls speak about Murders with Weird Backstories. Holly kicks things off with the bizarre tale of Sharon Lopatka before Gemma chats through the case of Hiroshi Maeue who had a very specific victim group. Holly once again forgets to push the button, she then suggests you un-ring your necrophilia bell, Producer Craig is on fire with sass, Gemma’s murderer is very strangley and Google argues with Gemma’s science. Production, recording and post production completed by Prod
S3 EPISODE 28: American Thanksgiving Murders
In Season 3 Episode 28 the girls cover American Thanksgiving Murders with Gemma kicking it off telling us all the utterly depressing story of Terri Lynn Hollis. Holly then goes over the family killing by Paul Michael Merhige. Holly starts things off dirty, there is a huge justice gap in Gemma’s case, Holly demands revenge on a corpse, red flags are flown, Gemma offends America slightly and Turkey is praised. The bird not the country. Shoutout to Facebook fan Melinda for this theme suggestion.Pr
S3 EPISODE 27: Family Murder Mysteries
In Season 3 Episode 27 the girls cover Family Murder Mysteries. Holly speaks about the creepy Hinterkaifeck Murders in Bavaria and Gemma covers the mystery of the Sodder Children – murder or not? Holly starts things off by ignoring the basics of podcasting, Gemma is glowing with health, the girls have strong conclusions and basically solve the cases themselves and Gemma hates her family (not entirely true at all). Shoutouts to Facebook fan Melinda, Superfan Catriona and Dave from the website. Th
S3 EPISODE 26: Murdered While Pregnant
In Season 3 Episode 26 the girls take a fan theme suggestion (thanks Carrie!) and cover cases of women who were Murdered While Pregnant. Gemma starts off with the story of Winifred Ransom and Holly then speaks about Reyna Angelica Marroquin.The girls are professionally unprepared in their shout-outs this week, the girls complain to the country of America regarding their selfish election thing, get confused over a British firework holiday and gently bully all the listeners. Patrick Stewart and Ho
S3 EPISODE 25: Clubland Murders
In episode 25, season 3, Gemma and Holly discuss Clubland Murders. Theme suggested by listener Jared Muppet. Shoutouts given to long time supporter of the podcast, Woody from Real Life Real Crime, and to superfan Oliver. Holly’s case is the mass shooting in a Florida nightclub, carried out by a terrible man called Omar Mateen. Gemma thanks Jared for suggesting her case, the murder of Angel Melendez by Michael Alig. Holly stressed out about how much Gemma’s recent illness effects her, Gemma claim
S3 EPISODE 24: Scottish Island Murders
In Season 3 Episode 24 the girls speak about Scottish Island Murders with Gemma covering the tragic case of Alesha MacPhail and then Holly goes into old timey times to speak about Angus MacPhee.Holly is in a rare positive mood and might be an alien, the girls diagnose mental illness via time travel, Gemma knows what cases bent boy parts and there is an update on Episode 20’s murderer. Who is still terrible at being a villain. Also Gemma is a witch. Shout-out to Egypt. And Oliver who suggested th
S3 EPISODE 23: Halloween Murder Special
In Season 3 Episode 23 the girls are back with some Spooky Halloween Murders! Holly starts it off with the horrible story of Ronald Clark O’Bryan and Gemma tells us about a monster named Eric Copple. Gemma is alive and telling you all about her organs (thanks everyone for all your lovely messages of support), the girls talk about their little trip to Skye with hill tumbling included, Holly’s driving is judged due to a rogue boob and a spider makes a short appearance. Shout-out to a Facebook Sup
S3 EPISODE 22: Which Murderer Flashback Interesting Body Disposals
In Season 3 Episode 22 the Which Murderer Team are dealing with a bit of an unexpected situation so are revisiting some older episodes for the next few weeks. This week we went for Interesting Body Disposals from Season 2 Episode 17Your intro from Holly includes:Bitterness. Complaints. Whining. A bad accent. In Episode 17 Season 2, Gemma and Holly cover murderers with 'Interesting Body Disposals'. Gemma covers the strange tale of Jim Smith who way back in oldie times ended up in an aquarium side
S3 EPISODE 21: Which Murderer Flashback Murderers on TV
In Season 3 Episode 21 the Which Murderer Team are dealing with a bit of an unexpected situation so are revisiting some older episodes for the next few weeks. This week we went for Murderers on TV from Season 1 Episode 46Your intro from Holly includes:Bitterness. Complaints. Whining. A bad accent. In **Episode 46** Gemma and Holly cover murderers who have been on the silver screen, but not for their crimes. Gemma speaks about the worst gameshow prize ever, Rodney Alcala and Holly talks about a s
S3 EPISODE 20: Which Murderer Flashback Murders at Sea
In Season 3 Episode 20 the Which Murderer Team are dealing with a bit of an unexpected situation so are revisiting some older episodes for the next few weeks. First up its Murders at Sea from Season 1. Two REALLY good cases. Your intro from Holly includes:Bitterness. Complaints. Whining. A bad accent. The term '100%' 7 too many times. As well as…Shoutouts for Crime Monthly Magazine, Facebook Group Members Carrie and Kristy, two great reviews from Saza and Stephen and a really entertaining email
S3 EPISODE 19: Murder Solved Through Exhumation
In Season 3 Episode 19 – Murder Solved Through Exhumation – Holly speaks about Donnie Rudd, then James Otto EarhartShoutouts for Transcripted Podcasts, Storyglass Media and Generation Why PodcastIn this episode Holly and Gemma criticize three countries, Holly hates ‘Intro Holly’ and it’s revealed the girls might have been drunk during that clip, it’s the days of never-ending rain, the girls emphasize that you shouldn’t dick name your twins, and Holly has bludgeoning on the mind. Production, reco
S3 EPISODE 18: Mean Girl Murders
In Season 3 Episode 18 – Mean Girl Murders – Gemma covers the Canadian case of Reena Virk from Holly’s Island and Holly goes on to speak about Skylar Neese. Shoutouts to Canadian Dani for the suggested theme and to our Facebook fan who we aren’t sure meant to pop up but we see you!In this episode Holly is a cookie feeder….some may say monster, the girls find out a superfan likes war and Gemma’s phobia makes a late appearance. Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig
S3 EPISODE 17: Bollywood Murders
In Season 3 Episode 17 – Bollywood Murders – Holly covers the horrific murder of Meenakshi Thapa and Gemma goes through the story of Brijmohan Sadanah. Shoutouts to our good friend Oliver (you cute little binger you…), Canadian Facebooker Graham and Canadian Dani who likes a little sneeze. In this episode everyone is distracted by the scheduled Pub lunch about to happen, the girls struggle very hard with all the names…and places….and basically everything in this episode, there is some serious d
S3 EPISODE 16: Thrill Killers
In Season 3 Episode 16 – Thrill Killers – Gemma covers the brutal murderers Christopher Jones and James Roughan from Australia and Holly talks through the horrific Toolbox Killers case. WARNING: This is a particularly disturbing episode with extreme graphic violence. Listener discretion is advised. Shoutouts to Superfan Catriona, a fabulous recommender and a lovely reviewer. In this episode Gemma is suffering a little with a hangover and Holly is overmassaged. The postman also stops by mid-reco
S3 EPISODE 15: Gold Diggers Who Murder
In Season 3 Episode 15 –Gold Diggers Who Murder – Holly starts us off with the story of a pretty poor excuse of a human named Desmond Campbell. Then Gemma goes on to tell us all about Vicky Efandis who had a George fixation. This episode launches rather aggressively before Holly goes on to declare war on Scottish insects. They are the worst. Both girls cheat a little on research and end up using the same source….and Gemma tries to charge people with mothers. Which might in fact be a very ef
S3 EPISODE 14: 1970's Murder
In Season 3 Episode 14 –1970’s Murder – Gemma covers ‘Bad Man’ Randy Kraft while Holly tells you all about Robert John Maudsley who we might like a little? Shoutouts for some lovely iTunes reviewers including ‘Canadian Danni and Super Husband Clive’In this episode Gemma goes and ruins Holly’s favourite pasta, Holly gives some amazing Serial Killer pro tips, three entire adults fail to math, we conclude that 12 kids is too many kids and there are no pet budgies allowed in prison. Production,
S3 EPISODE 13: Framing Others for Murder
In Season 3 Episode 13 – Framing Others for Murder – Holly tells the story of Rod Covlin who just so happens to be the king of assholes. Gemma then covers the story of Floyd Bledsoe who possibly has the worst family ever. In this episode Holly is very excited and scares her team, the English language continues to die via this podcast, names don’t get any easier and the US justice system takes a pretty big telling off. Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who ha
S3 EPISODE 12: Doctors Who Murder
In Season 3 Episode 12 –Doctors who Murder – Gemma takes on the bizarre story of Walter Freeman who was most definitely a fan of scrambled eggs, while Holly attempts to share the store of Marcell Petiot. Shoutouts to @podchaser and @behindthebastardsIn this episode the girls are finally reunited for recording and Holly is once again being produced by Producer Craig in the flesh. Gemma faces a dilemma when Holly tries to shoulder in on date night, Producer Craig is getting hard side eye and go
S3 EPISODE 11: Solved Their Own Murder
In Season 3 Episode 11 – Solved Their Own Murders – Holly tells the story of Grace May Brown who helped convict her killer after her death before Gemma goes on to tell the sad story of Simon Ng who blogged his murderer into a conviction. Shoutout to Natalie in Canada – thanks for recommending us! And thoughts go out to Holly’s Mom who is going through a hard time. In this episode we learn that Producer Craig has planted clues already to solve his own murder via Alexa, the girls figure out a
S3 EPISODE 10: Murdered by Police
In Season 3 Episode 10 – Murdered by Police, Gemma covers the tragic and horrifying death of Elliot Williams who died in custody after prolonged suffering. Holly then goes over the story of murderer Kevin Gregson in Canada. Shoutouts for some lovely fans who left five star reviews and a plug for the gorgeous new boutique shop @etonmessboutique The girls start out with a therapy session surrounding Holly’s conception….thanks mom….there are more English language struggles, Holly can sense the ju
S3 EPISODE 9: Homophobic Murders
In Season 3 Episode 9 – Homophobic Murder, Holly tells the story of Colin Ireland who was known as the ‘Gay Slayer’ and Gemma goes over the murders surrounding the Bondi Beach Attacks. In this episode Holly longs to be touched and stalks her nail people, Gemma broadcasts her lunch around the UK (possibly) and there are yet more math arguments. Math continues to be the source of all evils. Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who was rather fickle with his favour
S3 EPISODE 8: Jealousy and Murder
In Season 3 Episode 8 – Jealousy and Murder, Gemma covers the tale of Melanie Smith – not to be confused with SuperFan Mel…. although it was very exciting times for Holly briefly. Holly then goes on to break Gemma’s heart and mind with the horrific tale of murderer Gertrude Baniszewski. Shoutout to a lovely Facebook follower who is well on the way to SuperFan status and to True Crime Zone who added us to a fabulous list. Holly love list. https://www.truecrimezone.com/media/true-crime-podcasts/Ho
S3 EPISODE 7: Edinburgh Unsolved Murders
In Season 3 Episode 7 – Edinburgh Unsolved Murders, Holly kicks off the local tales of Murder with the sad story of the lovely Anne Ballantine. Gemma then goes on to cover the murder of Helen Kane – with some pretty big potential serial killer links. Shoutout to a lovely Facebook follower who gave some feedback on our ‘Murders that Shocked the World’ episode – she spells her name very Irishy. There are opposite weather conditions in Edinburgh as per usual, math makes another unwelcome appearance
S3 EPISODE 6: Serial Killers Released Early from Prison
In Season 3 Episode 6 – Serial Killers Released Early from Prison – Gemma starts with the Lainz Angels of Death which Holly correctly predicted she would (because nurses) and then Holly tells the tale of Charlene Gallego who did not find the third time lucky in the husband category of life. Shoutouts to lovely listeners who leave excellent reviews on iTunes (you give us life right now) and longtime listener Fleda who is our Canadian True Crime keeper straighter who sent us a couple messages whic
S3 EPISODE 5: Vampire Murderers
In Season 3 Episode 5 – Vampire Murderers are covered by the girls after Gemma finds her perfect case. Holly starts off with James Riva who lived in a state Holly refuses to spell. Gemma then goes on to tell the tale of Peter Kurten who was a bad bad man. Shoutouts to Holly’s Mother who did not give her murder information and Holly might have yelled at her a little….and a Facebook Fan shout-out who lifted our spirits. Holly is having a very bad apocalypse but has been given hope with her beans,
S3 EPISODE 4: Murders that Shocked the World
In Season 3 Episode 4 – Gemma and Holly cover ‘Murders that Shocked the World’. Gemma starts things off with the really sad story of James Bulger which was an unbelievable tragedy. Holly then rounds off the sadness with the murder of JonBenet Ramsey. Holly has a nervous breakdown at being late but firmly blames someone else all the way, there are sirens and mild panic, Gemma wins a contest while pushing her luck on her Tesco delivery and Cleo the cat runs to stop whatever drama is going on outsi
S3 EPISODE 3: Sexually Motivated Murders
In Season 3 Episode 3 – Holly and Gemma cover Sexually Motivated Murderers. Holly starts off with David Williams and his Canadian based murders. Gemma then goes over the story of Christopher Wilder…. which Holly almost covered as well. Despite being told clearly in writing that Gemma was covering it. Shoutouts for Superfan Natalie who left a lovely review and the quarantine episode from Fair City Podcast has dropped so Holly orders everyone to listen. https://www.fcpod.net/Gemma is at war with p
S3 EPISODE 2: Murder in Small Towns
In Season 3 Episode 2 – Gemma and Holly talk about people who Murder in Small Towns. Gemma starts things off with some informative information that Holly screws up before Gemma covers the story of William Immon. Holly then takes things super close to home on a street where she spent some time as a child….and the murder of Vesna Soos. Shout out to friend-fan Diane who was not bullied into listening but was tortured with a photo of Holly. Holly rolls out of a trash heap called home improvements an
S3 EPISODE 1: Murdering the Parents
Welcome to Season 3!In the Season 3 premiere - Episode 1 - Holly and Gemma talk about people who wanted their parents dead…not to be confused with Patricide…which is not to be confused with Pesticide. It’s a bit of a rabbit hole. Holly kicks things off with the story of Patricia (Patty) Columbo who had worse taste in men than Holly. Which is saying a lot. Then Gemma heads over to Canada to talk about Jennifer Pan who had super pushy parents up until the point she had them assassinated. Gemma
S2 EPISODE 52 : Killers with Shrines
In Episode 52, Season 2, Gemma and Holly celebrate the end of their second season and the beginning of Season 3 and their 2 year anniversary, which they then realise are all essentially the same thing. Gemma covers Russian serial killer Alexander Pichushkin, who loved a game of chess and pushing people. Holly covers earthquake preventer Herbert Mullin, who somehow couldn’t convince people of his legitimate mental illness. The girls struggle with time zones this week, there is an illegal block pa
S2 EPISODE 51: Deathbed Murder Confessions
In the Season 2 penultimate Episode - 51 - Holly and Gemma talk about Deathbed Murder Confessions from their lonely & ‘not coping well’ corners of the city. First Holly goes over the murder case of Christine Kett before Gemma launches into the horrific murder of Joan Harrison in 1975. In this episode Gemma struggles to make words escape her brain, Holly revisits her hatred for time travel when discussing a collaboration with the Fair City Podcast and a line is crossed with some definite advice
S2 EPISODE 50: PART TWO - Televised Trials
In Episode 50 Season 2 Gemma and Holly take another two-parter to cover Televised Trials. In Part One Gemma goes over the worst brother duo in the Menendez case and in Part Two Holly takes a dive into the cannibalistic world of Jeffrey Dahmer. Both cases very famously had televised trials. In this episode we learn how Holly is now a vegetable farmer, Gemma is helping to support her local community during the pandemic by ordering baked goods. Holly also decides she wants her own damn trial, Gemm
S2 EPISODE 50: PART ONE - Televised Trials
In Episode 50 Season 2 Gemma and Holly take another two-parter to cover Televised Trials. In Part One Gemma goes over the worst brother duo in the Menendez case and in Part Two Holly takes a dive into the cannibalistic world of Jeffrey Dahmer. Both cases very famously had televised trials. In this episode we learn how Holly is now a vegetable farmer, Gemma is helping to support her local community during the pandemic by ordering baked goods. Holly also decides she wants her own damn trial, Gemm
S2 EPISODE 49: Early Warning Signs
In Episode 49 Season 2 Holly and Gemma are looking for some ideas to keep Holly from becoming a very well researched murderer….and are also covering Murderers who had Early Warning Signs. Holly covers the story of Carroll Edward Cole who came from a family of androgynous namers. Gemma then goes into the case of David Berkowitz who had some interesting ‘head’ friends. There is a shout-out for Superfan Mel, some updates on how the girls have been affected by the pandemic (hint you should mail Hol
S2 EPISODE 48: 100th EPISODE! Worst Murders From Season 1
In Episode 48 Season 2 – OUR 100TH EPISODE OVERALL – Gemma and Holly are recording far away from each other due to the dumbest virus ever but are super excited to be covering their personal choices for WORST MURDERS FROM SEASON ONE. Gemma heads back to Episode 14, Season 1 (Matricide) for clips from the story of Ed Kemper. Then Holly springs back to Episode 31, Season 1 (Cannibals) to discuss Armin Meiwes. There are some fan shout-outs to some wonderful people, time travel for one birthday girl,
S2 EPISODE 47: Secrets and Murder
In Episode 47 Season 2, Holly and Gemma (still pre-lockdown) cover the intriguing topic of Secrets and Murder. Holly talks through fellow Canadian Brett Ryan (aka the ‘Crossbow Killer’) who was a complicated mix of good guy and murderer. Gemma then covers Mark Hacking who did the unimaginable to his closest connection. Holly struggles to describe this episode’s topic then yells at Gemma, Gemma is obsessed with a series about death and lying – Producer Craig has concerns, the girls point out the
S2 EPISODE 46: 1920's Murders
In Episode 46 Season 2, Gemma and Holly still have no idea life is about to get much more complicated with a virus and are cheerfully recording face to face to cover 1920's Murders. Gemma starts off with the messed up story of Gordon Stewart Northcott - who unfortunately was Canadian. Holly then chats through the spooky Hex House Murder which was a bit awkward. In this episode Producer Craig thinks the 1920's were good years. He is wrong. There is a lot of 'perking' going on this episode, naming
S2 EPISODE 45: PART 2 - Murderers With Head Injuries
In Episode 45 Season 2, Holly and Gemma make a two-parter special to cover Murderers with Head Injuries. Holly starts off in Part One with the coverage of Bobby Jo Long.There are some corrections to be make as Gemma can’t count bones while Holly wishes for 100 more in the human body and shout-outs for some fans including hashtag-name-thing @Why83km and a lovely South African listener whom the girls struggle to name. In Part One distracted mothering leads to a ridiculous level of childhood head i
S2 EPISODE 45: PART 1 - Murderers With Head Injuries
In Episode 45 Season 2, Holly and Gemma make a two-parter special to cover Murderers with Head Injuries. Holly starts off in Part One with the coverage of Bobby Jo Long.There are some corrections to be make as Gemma can’t count bones while Holly wishes for 100 more in the human body and shout-outs for some fans including hashtag-name-thing @Why83km and a lovely South African listener whom the girls struggle to name. In Part One distracted mothering leads to a ridiculous level of childhood head i
S2 EPISODE 44: Killed While Murdering
In Episode 44 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about 'Killers Who Died While Murdering' - which Gemma picked and subsequently ruined 3 days of Holly’s life. Gemma covers the story of Wayne Nance whose story should totally be a movie and then Holly chats through the death of murderer Neal Falls who liked to have options. Holly thinks getting up early, getting fuel and driving to Gemma’s is overachieving, Gemma points out the history of mobile homes to Holly, the girls declare that 9 children is too
S2 EPISODE 43: Body Disposal Stories
In Episode 43 Season 2, Holly and Gemma take a suggestion from 'Australian Al' and cover Body Storage Solutions. Holly pretty much takes the easiest option and covers the Snowtown Murders which do not involve Santa or Snow despite the happy sounding name. Gemma then goes on to destroy all our happy feelings with the sad tale of Junko Furuta and her murder.Holly is STILL hungry in this episode, Gemma has tongue issues with her words, Holly has useless friends who don't listen to the podcast anywa
S2 EPISODE 42: Murders from the 2010's
In Episode 42 Season 2, Gemma and Holly struggle their way through dates and times to bring you Murders from the 2010's. Gemma goes over the grisly tale of murderer Robert Bayne who murdered in Holly's old stomping grounds. Then Holly covers the short but tragic case of Murderer John Maden from Manchester.In this episode Holly can't carb so just stares longingly at Gemma's food, the paleness of the Scottish people is mentioned, Gemma explains what the Bebo age was and Holly's friend proves usele
S2 EPISODE 41: Murderers with No MO
In Episode 41 Season 2, Holly and Gemma finally return home from the Highlands of Scotland and are really quite miserable about it. The girls cover Murderers with No MO and Holly tentatively takes on the terrifying character Israel Keyes. Gemma then goes on to cover the South African Cedric Mack.Gemma gives a shout-out to a friend named Andrew who the girls then manage to also threaten, then there is another Instagram fan mention. Log cabin building times seem very unreasonable, 10 kids is too m
S2 EPISODE 40: Escaped Prison to Murder Again
In Episode 40 Season 2, Gemma and Holly are still in the Highlands of Scotland (listen, we do eventually make it home....). The girls talk about Murderers Who Escape Prison to Murder Again with Gemma kicking things off covering the case of Gary Tison and Randy Greenawalt. Holly then goes over the story of John Thomas Straffen. Some fan shout-outs happen from Instagram and there are mentions by and for the FC Podcast and Bloody Mess Podcasts. The girls passively aggressively most definitely argue
S2 EPISODE 39: Biters
In Episode 39 Season 2, Holly and Gemma wake up in a tender state in Highlands of Scotland. The girls talk about cases of Biters with Holly diving into the gory tale of the 'Butcher of Hanover' or "Fritz" Haarmann. Gemma then goes on to tell us all about the case of Stephanie Lazarus who got way obsessed with a guy. They aren't worth murdering for ladies!Some fan shout-outs happen from the Facebook Group and Instagram, Gemma has a fun achievement announcement, Holly has a lot of question marks,
S2 EPISODE 38: Well Educated Murderers
In Episode 38 Season 2, Gemma and Holly are in a tipsy state in Highlands of Scotland. The girls tackle cases of Well Educated Murderers with Gemma chatting through the story of Joseph Michael Swango who used his brain cells for bad doctoring and general human interacting. Holly then talks through the case of Amy Bishop who reached a tragic breaking point. Holly finds shampoo made by angels but sadly needs to sell a body organ to get restocked, Gemma struggles with words which leads to some wine
S2 EPISODE 37: Cop Killers
In Episode 37 Season 2, Holly and Gemma apparently now live in Highlands of Scotland. The girls cover the difficult topic of Cop Killers with Holly getting inspiration from Reddit on her case about Christopher Monfort who specifically targeted the police with his rage. Gemma then covers the historic Linwood Bank Robbery case from the outskirts of Glasgow, Scotland. The girls do not recommend bank robberies as a lucrative return for effort, clearly have no knowledge on concrete things (FYI it tak
S2 EPISODE 36: Scottish Highland Murders
In Episode 36 Season 2, Gemma and Holly are still recording on the road in the Highlands of Scotland. The girls cover the appropriately chosen theme of Scottish Highland Murders and Gemma starts the ball rolling with the story of Allister Wilson's death. Holly then tells us about the cold case murder of Renee Macrae which has some exciting new developments.Holly renames everything in Scotland north of Inverness 'the weird zone'.....change your maps immediately, Gemma invents a new language calle
S2 EPISODE 35: Hotel Murders
In Episode 35 Season 2, Holly and Gemma hit the road to record on location in the Highlands of Scotland. The girls cover Hotel Murders (making the thematic connection as they are staying in a hotel - genius!) and Holly talks about the Claypool Hotel which had it's share of fame, fortune and murders. Gemma then tells us about a horrific death at a hotel by Jesse McDonald who was a fancy criminal. Holly continues her brave struggle with time and math, some great advice on not helping your boyfrien
S2 EPISODE 34 : Alcohol and Murder
In Episode 34 Season 2, Holly and Gemma discuss murders that involved alcohol, which is fitting as both the girls are quite hungover. Gemma starts off with a disclaimer that her case about Angela Wrightson is very sad this week. Holly then discusses the murderer Jean Lanfray who had a fondness of absinthe and pretty much all other drinks involving alcohol. Holly shouts out the podcast Sharp and shares her own absinthe story from when she was in a questionable bar in Prague. Gemma tries and fail
S2 EPISODE 33: Murder Manhunts
In Episode 33 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk about Murder Manhunts with some sneaky country leavers. Holly covers Shane O'Brien who didn't have a bank account - which blows Holly's mind, followed by Gemma's telling of the bizarre murderer Luka Magnotta who was recently the subject of the Netflix documentary 'Don't F**k with Cats'. https://twitter.com/NetflixUK/status/1207347943298256896The girls handle criticism well in the morning recording session, Gemma goes HULK about men in clubs, Holly inv
S2 EPISODE 32: Religious Murders
In Episode 32 of Season 2, Gemma and Holly brave a hangover to bring you all some murders connected to Religion. There were a few to choose from sadly. Gemma talks about Lauren Stuart and her Jehovah's Witness family. Holly then takes on a Catholic murder committed on sacred ground by the priest Gerald Robinson.Holly has her life ruined by a pepper...not just any pepper...only the FIFTH HOTTEST PEPPER ON EARTH, Gemma is given a massive editing challenge and gives Holly a view into nunneries, ban
S2 EPISODE 31: Bosses Who Murder
In Episode 31 Season Two, Holly and Gemma cover cases of Bosses Who Murder. Holly goes into the tale of Hemy Newman who was crazy in love.....or just crazy. Gemma talks about the tragic and frustrating murder of Alisha and Ava Bromfield by the worst manager on earth. The girls start out with a weather and car safety segment which makes Producer Craig pull out all his eyelashes in frustration, Gemma uses an ominous voice, the girls discuss workplace 'rubbers', Holly suppresses burps and the girls
S2 EPISODE 30: Victorian Murders
In Episode 30 Season 2, the girls cover some grisly Victorian murders. Gemma goes for Frederick Bailey Deeming also known as 'Mad Fred' who failed at relationships and fatherhood dramatically. Holly then talks about Richard Dadd who was an accomplished artist and crazy person....perhaps even an Egyptian god.Holly ticks all her boxes, Gemma introduces Effie the Dog to the episode by gently accidentally booting her, Holly reveals the rules of Arson Club and the girls make it clear syphilis is not
S2 EPISODE 29: Stalking that Led to Murder
In Episode 29 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk about cases of stalking which sadly led to murder. Holly covers Robert John Bardow who went deep into TV land and mental disorder, followed by Gemma's telling of a sad case of domestic abuse/stalking that led to the murder of Shana Grice. Gemma shouts out her sister's roommate Claire who is the new podcast sister, Holly gives Gemma an update on one of her cases, the girls are surprised for the three thousandth time that murder is sad and Holly plugs m
S2 EPISODE 28: Murderers Who Wrote Books
In Episode 28 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who put pen to paper and wrote books about their crimes. Gemma speaks about Donald Gaskins Jr. aka 'PeeWee' who had adorable nicknames and gang names....but was very much not adorable. Then Holly covers Johann "Jack" Unterweger who had some hard core Mummy issues. Holly fails at the first hurdle, the girls get nostalgic for the days where you could just join a circus, Gemma talks through some casual cannibalism and the girls don't unde
S2 EPISODE 27: Case Zero
In Episode 27 Season 2, Holly and Gemma discuss cases that sparked their obsessions with true crime - CASE ZERO. Holly tries to cover the Black Dahlia but seeing as Gemma was TOO SELFISH to look into the future it's already been done, so she settles for a connected case and the murder of Gertrude Landon. Gemma then goes on to cover a murderer Ann Rule wrote about, Diane Downs. Holly is pretty aggressive about Gemma stealing her case a year ago, Gemma has a freakishly good memory, Gemma's murdere
S2 EPISODE 26: DECAPITATION
In Episode 26 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who lost their heads!....while decapitating people. Gemma covers the murderer Mathew Borges who took 'troubled teens' a step or ten too far and Holly speaks about the Kingsbury Run murders from the 1930s. The girls plug Gemma's guest appearance on the podcast 'Good Nurse Bad Nurse', Holly has another Reddit breakdown, the girls guess a movie correctly for the first time in history (wink wink Kevin Costner) and Holly give age specific m
S2 EPISODE 25: BURIED ALIVE
In Episode 25 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who buried their victims alive! Gemma covers the murder Stephen Small who had a pretty terrible kidnapping experience and Holly speaks about murderer Tiffany Ann Cole. The girls plug the Facebook Group hard and give much thanks to moderator Kimberlee! Gemma invents a new word that will definitely catch on, a construction worker is heavily critisized for his lack of skills, Holly admits to using the easiest research methods possible and
24: S2 E24 : GEMMAS AND MURDER
In Episode 24 Season 2, Gemma and Holly discuss cases involving Gemmas. Holly stars off with the case of young Gemma McCluskie, an actress who was sadly murdered by her own brother. Gemma discusses the wannabe serial killer Jemma Lilley who had the wrong heroes and a grandiose sense of importance. ⠀⠀ Gemma mistakenly advertises several products and gets annoyed at unobservant taxi drivers. Hol
23: S2 EPISODE 23: HOLLYS AND MURDER
In Episode 23 Season 2, Holly and Gemma cover...Hollys! - specifically ones who murder or are victims of murder. Surprisingly hard to find! Holly covers the case of Holly McFeature who you should never accept Iced Tea from. Gemma starts off this episode with the sad tale of Holly Jones who was taken far too soon. The girls give some fan shout-outs from iTunes Reviews and Instagram, Holly apologises for all the turkey confusion, the girls do mid-recording research (aka last minute) with results t
22: S2 EPISODE 22: DIARY KEEPERS
In Episode 22 Season 2, Gemma and Holly discuss the 1 of the 3 things that annoy Holly the most, murderers who keep diaries. Holly shares the tale of young Jason Massey who worked his way through the Triad and documented it all. Gemma discusses self proclaimed “strange character” and serial killer Robert Berdella. Who wasn’t just strange, he was a sadistic torturer and had the laziest way of getting rid of evidence. ⠀⠀Gemma can’t understand how no one noticed all the missing cats and dogs. Holly
21: S2 EPISODE 21: CHARMING MURDERERS
In Episode 21 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk through two stories of Murderers with Charm. Gemma starts off with Paul John Knowles, who has a little bit of sparkly vampire in his cheekbones. Then Holly moves on to William Theodore Durrant....who liked a church, or rather all the storage space available in a church. Gemma learns to say the word 'burglary' very carefully, Holly debunks a psychic, Canadian Thanksgiving is ruined by a Canadian and the girls finally break Producer Craig. Skip though t
20: S2 EPISODE 20: SENTENCED TO DEATH BUT INNOCENT
In Episode 20 Season 2, Holly and Gemma cover two cases of people who were sentenced to death but were later proven innocent. Holly goes through the case of Timothy John Evans from Wales who confessed to a crime he most definitely did not commit. Then Gemma talks about the saddest case Holly has ever heard.....Joe Arridy. Listen with tissues. A happy shout-out to a fan kicks off this episode which then sinks way down into bad times and the discovery that foot tuberculosis IS a thing. Holly's cas
19: S2 EPISODE 19: TERRIBLE CHILDHOODS
In Episode 19 Season 2, Gemma and Holly chat through the terrible childhoods of two murderers. Gemma talks about the bizarre case of Gypsy Rose Blanchard. Which Holly gets excited about despite it totally not being a real surprise. Holly then speaks about the prolific vigilante murderer Pedro Rodriguez Filho who is a YouTube legend - apparently. Holly is confused by how someone with a skinned knee ends up with a wheelchair, Gemma has a hanger and Holly is taught Spanish. Also Holly’s Mum has a
18: S2 EPISODE 18, PART 2: CRIMINALLY INSANE MURDERERS
In Episode 18 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk about a particularily terrifying category of murder - Criminally Insane Killers. Holly takes a recommendation from Ladynickmiller on Reddit (https://www.reddit.com/user/ladynickmiller) and covers the 'Vampire of Sacramento' - Richard Chase. Gemma then goes through the murders committed by Michael Charles Hayes. Gemma feels masses of sympathy for Richard Chase's roomates who literally could not have drawn a worse roomate card, Holly gets fed up with it
18: S2 EPISODE 18, PART 1: CRIMINALLY INSANE MURDERERS
In Episode 18 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk about a particularily terrifying category of murder - Criminally Insane Killers. Holly takes a recommendation from Ladynickmiller on Reddit (https://www.reddit.com/user/ladynickmiller) and covers the 'Vampire of Sacramento' - Richard Chase. Gemma then goes through the murders committed by Michael Charles Hayes. Gemma feels masses of sympathy for Richard Chase's roomates who literally could not have drawn a worse roomate card, Holly gets fed up with it
17: S2 EPISODE 17: INTERESTING BODY DISPOSALS
In Episode 17 Season 2, Gemma and Holly cover murderers with 'Interesting Body Disposals'. Gemma covers the strange tale of Jim Smith who way back in oldie times ended up in an aquarium side-show and Holly ruins everybody's day with the horrific crimes of Enriqueta Marti Ripolles - who is now knows as Ricki as Holly almost swallowed her own nostrils trying to pronounce it. The girls record in the EH EM....before noon....aka way too early for their liking. Holly has the flu and zero feelings. G
16: S2 EPISODE 16: ROAD RAGE MURDERS
In Episode 16 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk through 'Road Rage Murders'. Holly speaks about the conviction of Kenneth Noye and Gemma covers Gary Durham from Florida. Holly is violently torn from her hippie colony school roots when Gemma slaps real world gangster school crime rackets at her, Gemma weaves a twisted tale of karma that has Holly choking on air and Producer Craig causes endless trouble as per usual with his silence and sitting still WITH ATTITUDE. Promo from Trueish Crime Production
15: S2 EPISODE 15: VICTIMS IN THE ARCHITECTURE
In Episode 15 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk through 'Victims in the Architecture'. Gemma talks about Anthony Sowell who was the poster boy for 'Crack is Whack' and then Holly covers the story of eccentric and jerkfaced Mr. Nichols. The girls don't support having 12 children in the same house, Holly explains why she can't live on a farm with an orchard, Gemma judges people who ride lawnmowers like ponies and it is decided nobody has a toothless monster coming at them on their wish-list.Promo fro
14: S2 EPISODE 14: ONE VICTIM, MULTIPLE MURDERERS
In Episode 14 Season 2, Holly and Gemma discuss cases where one victim was killed by more than one murderer. Holly covers the tragic case of Stephen Lawrence (https://www.stephenlawrence.org.uk/?gclid=Cj0KCQjw753rBRCVARIsANe3o47uGsSmjCl_jOQ8wKgSyYKOzzknaLJKelyWlLE971yXvSVSuRzEC5EaAtTgEALw_wcB) who changed the course of the UK legal system with his untimely death. Gemma then goes into the grisly murder of Louise Jensen in Cyprus by three British soldiers (one of which now lives a bit too close fo
13: S2 EPISODE 13: SOLVED USING FINGERPRINTS
In Episode 13 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about crimes that were solved using fingerprints. Gemma travels to New Zealand (verbally) to chat through the tale of Dennis Gunn, who was really not up to date on crime technology. In that he was an idiot about covering up his involvement. Holly then chats through the groundbreaking case of the Stratton Brothers in London. Holly and Gemma are bossed around endlessly by Producer Craig, Gemmas murderer pretty much touched all the things he could in lif
12: S2 EPISODE 12: BLACK WIDOWS
In Episode 12 Season 2, Holly and Gemma cover two tales of Black Widows (the ladies not the spider, because Holly nopes out of anything spider related). Holly starts off with the tale of the 'dull normal' Evelyn Dick and Gemma talks about Mary Elizabeth Wilson who totally liked an alternative lifestyle. Holly gets sugar boosts from Producer Craig which results in memory loss and problems speaking (copyrighting the term 'killdren') - which is probably the opposite of what he wanted. Gemma doesn't
11: S2 EPISODE 11: MURDERERS WITH NICKNAMES
In Episode 11 Season 2, Gemma and Holly chat through two cases of Murderers with Nicknames, both terribly accurate and ridiculous. The girls delve into the dark decade of the seventies....with Gemma covering 'The Doodler' and Holly speaking about 'Charlie Chop-off'. Holly starts off the episode by ruining 'Forrest Gump', then in short order ruining Gemma's entire case. Gemma forgives her (probably) because they are totally channelling each other and despite trying to empathise with men, Gemma do
10: S2 EPISODE 10: MURDERED WITH FOOD
In Episode 10 Season 2, Holly and Gemma talk about their two favourite topics....food and murder. Holly covers the sad case of Veronica Cirella and her terrible use of a wonderful candy. Gemma then goes over the double murderers Sofia Sam and Arun Kamalasanan who were super terrible at hiding things. Holly starts off the episode by completely screwing up her credit to whichever of the people she sees daily suggested this topic, Cleo makes a grand appearance which puts Gemma on edge, Producer Cra
9: S2 EPISODE 9: OLD TIMEY LONDON MURDERS
In Episode 9 Season 2, Gemma and Holly cover 'Old Timey London Murders' - a place where people always seem to get stabby. Gemma covers the story of Adelaide Bartlett who may have been an aristocrat or just a normal human. Holly then talks about The Barnes Mystery where a woman named Katherine was super talented at avoiding full time employment. Holly gets excited about pears because all life is about food, Gemma confuses Holly with platonic wedding vows, magnets are used in childbirth, hats
8: S2 EPISODE 8: TEACHERS WHO MURDER
Gemma covers the story of terrible teacher Violet Berling who taught the horrific craft of accordion playing. Holly chats through the tale of teacher Carla Ann Hughes who threw away a promising life over a dude.This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4106338/advertisement
7: S2 EPISODE 7: MURDERERS WITH DISTINGUISHING FEATURES
In Episode 7 Season 2, Holly and Gemma chat about 'Murderers with Distinguishing Features' which was a suggestion from the continuously challenging Producer Craig. Gemma covers the famous (and poorly parented) Henry Lee Lucas and Holly covers Tsutomu Miyazaki who was the stuff of nightmares. Holly starts off the episode by complaining about everything on earth, Gemma points out the obvious to Holly, Holly then gets too cocky about her Japanese skills, and the girls are emphatic about their cho
6: S2 EPISODE 6: WRESTLERS WHO MURDER
In Episode 6 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk cover the crimes of two 'Wrestlers Who Murder' which was a suggestion from the ever challenging Producer Craig. Holly covers fellow Canadian Christopher Benoit and Gemma talks about the 'little old lady killer' and Lucha libre wrestler Juana Barraza. Producer Craig kicks off this episode with a wizard impression, Holly makes it very clear she does NOT care about wrestling but remains passionate about Canadian anything, Gemma uncovers a hatred for th
5: S2 EPISODE 5 - VICTIMS IN THE FOOD CHAIN
In Episode 5 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk through the especially disturbing way some murderers dispose of their victim's bodies....in the Food Chain. Gemma talks about the unstable Australian woman who liked a Sunday roast, Katherine Knight. She really freaks Holly out this week. Then Holly tells the sad tale of Charlene Downs and many other young girls from Blackpool. Holly starts off on a shaky foot after eating candy that had been roasted in the car for 10 hours (we are taking applications
4: S2 EPISODE 4 - TROPHY KILLERS
In Episode 4 Season 2, Holly and Gemma get into the spirit of hoarding by covering Murderers who Kept Trophies - or Trophy Killers.This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4106338/advertisement
3: S2 EPISODE 3 - PART 2: SPREE MURDERERS
In Episode 3 Season 2, Gemma and Holly take two episodes to cover the topic of Spree Murderers.This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4106338/advertisement
3: S2 EPISODE 3 - PART 1: SPREE MURDERERS
In Episode 3 Season 2, Gemma and Holly take two episodes to cover the topic of Spree Murderers.
2: S2 EPISODE 2 - COPYCAT MURDERS
Copycat Murders and a 'Which Would You Rather' debate - from the Which Murderer Team!This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/4106338/advertisement
1: S2 EPISODE 1 - WORST MURDER DEFENSE
Our first episode of Season 2 focuses on Murderers with the worst defences. Holly and Gemma get off to a bad start by forgetting where and when they first met! Then Holly speaks about Scott Falater who killed his wife in the garden in front of his neighbour. Gemma moves on to her case, speaking about barmaid Sandie Craddock. Both cases involve very strange defence arguments. Holly and Gemma to have to call in Google to help out near the end to answer questions each other have raised, but Google
52: EPISODE 52: HUNTED ON THE WEB
In **Episode 52** - the end Season One! - Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who used the internet to hunt their victims, instead of using it for what the good Lord Almighty intended...shopping and porn. Gemma covers the tragic story of murderer Lisa Montgomery and Holly talks about a truly monstrous employer and sadomasochist John Edward Robinson. Holly can't read her own writing and makes some uneducated guesses trying to figure out a state, Gemma struggles with her decision this week vocall
51: EPISODE 51: INCEST THAT LED TO MURDER
In **Episode 51** Holly and Gemma tackle the ultimate taboo of incest, then take it to the next level in cases that led to murder. Holly chats through the story of the Bakeland family, who in a weird 'butterfly effect' sort of way eventually led to a Sea Turtle getting something extracted from it's nostrils. Gemma speaks about Ryan Wyngarden who was eventually convicted for murdering his sister, who he was a bit too close with growing up. Gemma is totally high on energy drinks for this entire ep
50: EPISODE 50: MURDERED AT WORK
In **Episode 50** Gemma and Holly talk about cases where the victims were killed while at work, like work wasn't bad enough. Gemma talks about convicted killer Richard Farley who committed the cowardly crime of stalking and harassing his victim Laura Black before attempting to murder her in the workplace, killing many others in the process. Then Holly chats through the story of Raymond Clark III who was found guilty of the horrifying murder of Annie Le. Holly pretty much stays focused on her nee
49: EPISODE 49: MURDERERS SEEKING THE PUBLIC'S HELP
In **Episode 49** Holly and Gemma cover a couple of murderers who had the audacity to seek the public's help for the crimes they had committed. Gemma talks about the convicted killer John Tanner who killed his fiance of approximately 12 hours and Holly goes through the story of Tracie Andrews who was found guilty of the brutal murder of Lee Harvey. Holly starts off claiming to be candy deprived but very quickly makes a shocking confession, Gemma instructs Craig to stop with his ridiculous head
48: EPISODE 48: MURDERED ON HOLIDAY
In **Episode 48** Gemma and Holly talk about Murders that happen while on holiday. Which is the worst kind of holiday to have. Gemma goes for Bruce Beresford-Redman with the murder of his wife Monica in Mexico and Holly covers Bradley John Murdoch who was convicted of killing Peter Faconio in Australia. Holly kicks things off by moaning about rain and finger bruises, Gemma decides she’s never going to the Southern Hemisphere, the girls go off on a few tangents as per usual because daylight hours
47: EPISODE 47: URBAN LEGENDS
In **Episode 47** Holly and Gemma chat through some Urban Legends involving murders from both reality and fiction. Gemma goes for the cannibal Scottish family led by Sawney Bean and Holly covers a relatively new legend, The Alice Killings. The episode starts off with Producer Craig setting himself on fire, there is an update on the Jack the Ripper case, the girls talk about how amazingly terrifying Japanese horror is and the question of why cannibals don't fish is answered by Gemma. Also Holly e
46: EPISODE 46: MURDERERS ON TV
In **Episode 46** Gemma and Holly cover murderers who have been on the silver screen, but not for their crimes. Gemma speaks about the worst gameshow prize ever, Rodney Alcala and Holly talks about a serial killer cook names Stephen Port. The girls struggle a little with Geography (also Math, unrelated to this episode), Holly nopes out of a multiple strangling situation, the girls do not recommend using the same graveyard for body dumping and completely lose their minds over lazy nicknaming prac
45: EPISODE 45: CONVICTED WITH NO BODY
In **Episode 45** Holly and Gemma talk about some murderers who were convicted despite there being no bodies found of the victims. Gemma speaks about the terrible road tripper David Gilroy and Holly covers an absolutely terrible son and brother named John Perry. The girls go back to 17th century England to talk about a whacky 'Gone Girl' situation, Holly is an expert on cadaver dogs since listening to a 5 minute segment of 'Stuff You Should Know', Gemma says 'hi' to everybody and starts a new th
44: EPISODE 44: CLAIMING INNOCENCE
In Episode 44 Gemma and Holly talk about some murderers who are still **Claiming Innocence**….despite being found dead-ass guilty. Gemma speaks about Pamela Smart and Holly covers Dr. Jeffrey MacDonald . The girls once again forget how to make a podcast, Gemma sets Holly up and Holly fails the test, giggles ensure at the name of an unfortunate high-school and Gemma has to deal with another spouse murder. She’s starting to give Producer Craig the side-eye daily.Production, recording and fancy han
43: EPISODE 43: BASED ON A TRUE STORY
In Episode 43 Holly and Gemma watch some movies and TV shows in order to cover their theme this week - **Based on a True Story**. Holly covers _‘The Frozen Ground’_ which is the story of Robert Christian Hansen….a truly horrible hunter….and Gemma speaks about _‘American Crime Story’_ and the murder of Gianni Versace by Andrew Cunanan. Holly complains about her movie (a lot) and Nicholas Cage, both girls blank on half of Gemma’s story and the consensus is that being hunted in the wilderness by a
42: EPISODE 42: MEXICAN MURDERS
In Episode 42 Gemma and Holly decide to butcher the Spanish language and cover murderers in Mexico (which is the land of Holly's third favourite food group). Gemma covers Raul Marroquin who had a very flawed get rich quick scheme and Holly talks about Gregorio Cardenas Hernandez who got the bad end of encephalitis. Not that there is a good end. This week the girls attempt and then totally give up on Mexican names (who picked this topic anyway?), Holly described another murder DURING her murder t
41: EPISODE 41: WORST FEARS HOLLY - STRANGULATION
In Episode 41 Holly and Gemma continue discussing murders surrounding worst fears, this time Holly's issues with Strangulation. Gemma covers Susan Newell who was the worst Spiderman impressionist and Holly talks about Edward Leonski who was exceptionally quick at overstaying his international welcome. This week the girls both admit to having suffered through their worst fears, Holly talks a bit too much about Bob Ross, Gemma might have a John obsession based on her choice of story, and Gemma tea
40: EPISODE 40: WORST FEARS: GEMMA - DROWNING
In Episode 40 Gemma and Holly celebrate the podcast being a full term baby by discussing murders surrounding worst fears, in this case Gemma's. Drowning. Gemma covers Ryan Widmer who was not super fast at tubby time rescue and Holly chats through Dennis Nilsen who had storage space challenges. This week the girls tell off a naughty jury, Holly thinks everyone might be a swinger, Gemma has strong feelings about dead body funerals involving children and the girls are probably both psychologists no
39: EPISODE 39: MOBILE MURDERS
In Episode 39 Holly and Gemma discuss murders on moving vehicles….of various public transportation varieties. Gemma covers the train loving Franz Muller (who we don't think has a yogurt connection) and Holly chats through the bus taking Vince Li. Important to note that Holly is violently opposed to public transportation and is not in the least surprised it has led to many deaths. This week the girls do not understand 19th century first aid, Holly deletes an entire Canadian province (sorry Saskat
38: EPISODE 38: RUSSIAN MURDERERS
In Episode 38 Gemma and Holly talk about some Russian murderers who targeted the elderly and were probably almost definitely soul mates, Irina Viktorovna Gaidamachuk and Maxim Petrov. This week the girls decide that English is the only language they will attempt to speak occasionally, they might actually be accidental witches and they consider building a serial killer tinder when they discover they've found murdering soul mates.Production, recording and technical science things all completed by
37: EPISODE 37: ELDERLY MURDERERS
In Episode 37 Gemma and Holly discuss the surprising stories of elderly people who commit murder. Gemma covers the oldest couple put on death row for murder, Ray and Faye Copeland, while Holly discusses the tragic case of 100 year old Michael Juskin. This week the girls go back to an earlier episode to figure out why listeners are yelling at them, talk about the relative temperature of soup (a lot), Gemma decides she doesn't want Producer Craig to kill her with an ax, and Holly clarifies which b
37: EPISODE 36 (PART 2) : ASSASSINATIONS
Episode 36 is a special 2 parter focussing on Assassinations! Part 1 is Gemma discussing the famous JFK killing and Holly talks about Ghandi’s shooting in Part 2\. Both girls have slightly personal aspect to each case, they debate the tackiness of some memorial sites, and Holly nearly mixes up Ghandi with another peace loving man. We also realise just how cursed/unfortunate the Kennedy clan was. The ladies choose at the end, how they would have rather been assassinated, and make a fairly easy de
36: EPISODE 36 (PART 1) : ASSASSINATIONS
Episode 36 is a special 2 parter focussing on Assassinations! Part 1 is Gemma discussing the famous JFK killing and Holly talks about Ghandi’s shooting in Part 2\. Both girls have slightly personal aspect to each case, they debate the tackiness of some memorial sites, and Holly nearly mixes up Ghandi with another peace loving man. We also realise just how cursed/unfortunate the Kennedy clan was. The ladies choose at the end, how they would have rather been assassinated, and make a fairly easy de
35: EPISODE 35: GLASGOW MURDERS
**Episode 35** focuses on another Scottish city - **Glasgow**! Gemma covers Madeleine Hamilton Smith and Holly discusses Jean Barclay Waddell who is a bit of an internet Waldo. This week the girls record in daylight hours and it doesn’t seem to help, Holly finally follows legal advice, Gemma helps out with words Holly can’t say, Gemma talks about an enraging male victim and both girls have strong views on their choices.Production, recording and technical science things all completed by Craig. He
34: EPISODE 34 : SIGNATURE KILLERS
The 34th episode focuses on Signature Killers, Gemma covers Albert DeSalvo which Holly is super excited about, and Holly discusses Charles Albright (spoiler alert, he’s a fan of pretty eyes). Holly struggles to talk at times due to candy eating, but that of course takes priority. Gemma tries her hand at reciting poetry, and Holly knows more about Gemma’s case than she does. Gemma thinks that stealing a hammer deserves 2 years in jail and both ladies invent facts about someone’s post-conviction d
33: EPISODE 33 - LEGAL MURDERS
In episode 33, Gemma and Holly discuss Legal Murders. Wait, is there such a thing? Listen to Gemma and Holly realise that they may have got the entire subject wrong but go with it anyway. Holly discusses a murderer with perhaps the best name ever, Levi Boone Helm who seems to have been born bad and Gemma covers killer Hamida Djandoubi, the charming abuser who lived in Paris. Both murderers were sentenced and put to death for their crimes and the ladies debate which way they would have rather bee
32: EPISODE 32: GERMAN
In Episode 32 Gemma and Holly chat through a couple of murders from the homeland of Holly’s family....Germany! Holly covers a real charmer from ye oldie times named Gesche Gottfried and Gemma talks about Murderer Reiner Sturm who went to sailing school. Which Holly did not know was an actual thing. Minds were blown. Gemma explains what a pimp uniform is, Holly finds out about poorly named British foods, Gemma is denied story time, Holly swears off due diligence and Gemma explains what a merkin i
31: EPISODE 31: CANNIBALS
In Episode 31 Holly and Gemma focus on some strange culinary compulsions with cases involving Cannibalism!....they discuss the tragic cases of Armin Meiwes and Issei Sagawa . The girls find out that cannibals like a good chat room, Holly proves that doing due diligence doesn't pay off, they critique cooking methods, Gemma is rendered speechless, they discover cannibals turn cannibal younger than expected and Gemma upsets Holly with lip eating tales. Production, recording and mixing completed by
30: EPISODE 30: CHRISTMAS MURDERS
Merry/Happy Christmas everybody! Our 30th episode focuses on Christmas murders....we discuss the tragic murder of Joanna Yeates and the Christmas Day massacre committed by Bruce Pardo. We realise that Holly is way too presumptuous to sit on a jury. Holly also completely traumatises Gemma and she will never look at Santa the same again. Then we propose a new mating ritual that is bound to be successful with the human race.Production, recording and mixing completed by Santa’s little elf, Craig. He
29: EPISODE 29: RITUALISTIC
Episode 29 concerns Ritualistic Murders with Holly discussing killer Moises Meraz-Espinoza, the unnecessary ‘i’ in the name makes the name less biblical, listen to find out why. Gemma discusses Welsh killer Matthew Hardman, a wannabe vampire. Find out that Holly knows a surprising amount about Underworld, Gemma struggles with microphone issues and Holly makes a controversial decision when they debate Which Murderer they would chose. Recording and post production completed by Craig, he’s been rec
28: EPISODE 28: REOFFENDERS
In **Episode 28**, Gemma and Holly discuss two cases of **Reoffending Murderers**. Gemma chats through the incredible case of the Genesee River Killer Arthur Shawcross and Holly talks about the horrific crimes of Paul O’Hara. Holly forgets how to make words, Gemma debunks Holly’s theory on a multiple personality disorder defence, Holly screams her views resulting in Producer Craig’s deafness, and Gemma sets a decapitation challenge.Recording and post production completed by Producer Craig. He li
27: EPISODE 27: FEMALE MURDERERS
In **Episode 27**, Holly and Gemma discuss two cases of **Female Murderers**. Holly starts off with the French murderer Cecile Brossard and Gemma follows with a dark tale about serial killer Dorothea Puente. Holly continues her life-long struggle with name pronunciation (as well as staying awake), Gemma is shocked by the Swiss probation system and Producer Craig is outed as a part-time meanie.Recording and post production completed by Producer Craig. He continues to use his magic button box to m
26: EPISODE 26 : HONOUR KILLINGS
In episode 26, Holly and Gemma discuss two cases of honour killings. Gemma starts off with the murder of Shafilea Ahmed and Holly talks about Tulay Goren. Both cases are fairly similar this week, and there may be some soap boxing and also a quick cameo from a soap star that neither Holly or Gemma know. Holly hopes that science can solve their shared curiosity about possible bodies in the Thames and also talk body language experts. Recording and post production completed by the honourable Craig,
25: EPISODE 25: MURDER BOMBS
In Episode 25 Gemma and Holly took a theme suggestion from The [Bottomless Pit Podcast](https://itunes.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-bottomless-pit-podcast/id1260983563?mt=2) and covered Murder Bombs! Or rather, people that kill using Bombs. Kind of. They talk about The Bath School Disaster of the 1920's and then move on to the Tokyo Subway Sarin Attack – covering psychopaths and cults all in one shot. In this episode the girls eat some fan gift candy and proceed to flail their arms wildly, Holly tha
24: EPISODE 24 : MURDERS AT SEA
Episode 24 centres around murders at sea, or is it murders on the sea, or is it murders involving water? Who knows?! Gemma’s case is about the murderer Peter Madsen, a big fan of rockets and submarines. Holly discusses former orange power ranger John Jacobson junior. We do not know how boats work, another thing to add to the list of these we know little about but will make strong statements on. There’s a lot of debate on Which Murderer Gemma and Holly will choose this week. Recording and post pr
23: EPISODE 23: MOVIE MURDERS
In Episode 23 Gemma and Holly take a break from real life and cover Movie Murders! They talk about ‘Double Jeopardy’ and then move on to ‘Friday the 13th ‘ – some fabulously gruesome movie murder stories. In this episode the accuracy of romantic scenes is picked apart, Holly gives more crime scene advice, Gemma tries to defend Kevin Bacon and Holly refuses to let her.Recording and all the other tech stuff done by Producer Craig who spent hours on the floor growling at our microphone adjustments.
23: EPISODE 22 : WITCHES
Episode 22 is our Halloween Special episode where we focus on Witches who have murdered. Gemma covers Diana Haun, and Holly has chosen the bizarrely spelled Cherrylle Dell. Holly again finds life difficult, this time it’s pronunciation. Gemma keeps wishing her life away and thinking its next year already. And there’s a special guest, Effie, who’s a very good girl! Listen to us choose Which Witch murderer we would have murder us. Recording and mixing completed by this stranger who keeps on watchi
21: EPISODE 21, PART 2: ENGLISH HEAVY-HITTERS
In Episode 21 Gemma and Holly release two episodes covering the massive cases of some English Heavy-Hitter Murderers. They cover the horrific cases of **Fred and Rose West**, then **Peter Sutcliffe** who are some of the most prolific and psychopathic serial killers in English history. In this two-parter they talk about why it’s not a good idea to have a murder signature, they start a new Dr. Suess story without even trying, everyone is getting pregnant via their own family members, Christmas swe
21: EPISODE 21, PART 1: ENGLISH HEAVY HITTERS
In Episode 21 Gemma and Holly release two episodes covering the massive cases of some English Heavy-Hitter Murderers. They cover the horrific cases of **Fred and Rose West**, then **Peter Sutcliffe** who are some of the most prolific and psychopathic serial killers in English history. In this two-parter they talk about why it’s not a good idea to have a murder signature, they start a new Dr. Suess story without even trying, everyone is getting pregnant via their own family members, Christmas swe
22: EPISODE 20: CELEBRITIES WHO MURDER
In episode 20 we conclude that celebrities are people too and discuss Celebrities who Murder. Gemma covers creepy music producer Phil Spector, a man who didn’t rock the baldness but had a habit of threatening people with guns. Holly picked Sons of Anarchy actor, Johnny Lewis aka ‘halfsack’. Blame it all on Tom Cruise and Scientology. But still, be scared by them too. Holly struggles to pick this week, but that’s because there is a cat involved. Do not come between a woman and her cat! Recording
21: EPISODE 19: IRISH
In Episode 19 Gemma and Holly take a suggestion from Gemma’s Mum and talk about Irish Murders. They cover killers Gerard Toal and Graham Dwyer and find out that Holly is worse at Irish place names than math. Gemma redeems herself with her Irish heritage…mostly. In this episode they discuss what age you should definitely start committing murder, how fire hoses work, why dogs should only fetch femur bones and discover a new way to get rid of evidence.Recording and all the other tech stuff done by
20: EPISODE 18: SOUTH AFRICAN
In episode 18 Gemma and Holly take a suggestions from Holly’s lovely South African man and discuss some not so lovely South African men. One is a s**thole and the other is a Kock. Gemma continues to forget what she is actually doing in her life and Holly can’t count without doing the strangest of voices. It’s so funny that we have had that part playing on repeat since we recorded. We are required to put this disclaimer out that we really tried to say all the names and places correctly but they a
19: EPISODE 17: BIZARRE MURDERS
In Episode 17 Gemma and Holly take a suggestion from Producer Craig and tackle the tragically hilarious topic of BIZARRE MURDERS. They cover killer Debra Sue Hewitt and victim Ramon Novarro – who Holly is determined to link with a famous singer despite having no link to a famous singer….probably. In this episode they discuss how impossible it is for other people to describe this podcast, if prosthetic limbs bend (hint: they do), there are struggles with name pronunciations and a weird game of li
18: EPISODE 16: MURDERED CELBRITIES
In Episode 16 Holly and Gemma dive into MURDERED CELEBRITIES. They cover Charles Lindbergh Jr. and Captain James Cook.....where Gemma goes incognito, Holly declares the first crossing of the Atlantic by air to be stupid and Producer Craig gets creeped out. They unravel the suspicious characters associated with the famous kidnapping and how a famous explorer got murdered while kidnapping a king.Recording and all the other plugging stuff in bits done by the fabulous Producer Craig. He has also now
17: EPISODE 15: WRONGFULLY CONVICTED
Episode 15 focuses on a sometimes forgotten victim group - WRONGFULLY CONVICTED. Discussed are Craig Richard Coley (for the murder of Rhonda and Donald Wicht) and Randall Dale Adams (for the murder of officer Robert Wood) where Gemma and Holly dissect the US criminal justice system in a judgy way, make (totally reasonable) demands for candy from the kind person who suggested this topic, Holly cheers Gemma up with a MASSIVE link in her case to a newly revealed serial killer and everyone gets depr
15: EPISODE 14, PART 1 : MATRICIDE
Episode 14 is a special two-parter focussing on MATRICIDE - the murder of mothers (Sorry Mum/Mom!) We discuss Ed Kemper in Part 1 and Robert Coombes in Part 2\. There is Barbie mutilation and chocolate raisins, it’s like a child’s birthday party! Holly finds out how dangerous the microphones can be, and reveals her very bizarre choice for her funeral song! Also find out which of Holly’s long lost relatives are featured in part 2! Our choice of Which Murderer we would rather kill us could be quit
16: EPISODE 14, PART 2 : MATRICIDE
Episode 14 is a special two-parter focussing on MATRICIDE - the murder of mothers (Sorry Mum/Mom!) We discuss Ed Kemper in Part 1 and Robert Coombes in Part 2\. There is Barbie mutilation and chocolate raisins, it’s like a child’s birthday party! Holly finds out how dangerous the microphones can be, and reveals her very bizarre choice for her funeral song! Also find out which of Holly’s long lost relatives are featured in part 2! Our choice of Which Murderer we would rather kill us could be quit
14: EPISODE 13: AUSTRALIAN
In episode 13 Holly and Gemma cover AUSTRALIAN murders but can’t remember why. They discuss murderers Francesco Magione and Matthew Wales, make some strange noises, Gemma teaches Holly how to sell drugs from an ice cream van, Producer Craig re-enacts a death scene for us and Gemma’s murderer is the worst at covering up murder. Listen to find out Which Murderer we would rather kill us in Australia!Editing was done by Holly late at night, while covered in chocolate cookie smears. Recording and pro
13: EPISODE 12: MEDICAL MURDERS
In episode 12 Gemma and Holly get into a couple cases of MEDICAL MURDER. They discuss murdering nurses Roger Dean and Kristen Gilbert, Gemma has the plague and sings smelly cat and Holly judges names and expresses her hatred repeatedly desperate-women-nurse-murderers. Listen to find out Which Murderer we would rather take care of us in hospital!Recording, editing and post production completed with our endless thanks and constant complaints, by Craig…..who edits everything he touches with a wink
12: EPISODE 11: OCCULT
In episode eleven Gemma and Holly cover two occult murderers: the OTO Cult (probably) murder of Howard Green and Carol Marron and Adolfo Jesus Constanzo….who all liked a good murder spell. They discuss how Holly’s mother wishes she was a better German, why you shouldn’t walk to Mexico for a night out, Holly refuses to disclose her age, and Gemma has the plague. Find out which occult murderer we would pick to knock us off out of the these terrible choices.Holly edited this episode and still hates
10: EPISODE 10: ROYAL MURDERS
In episode 10 Gemma and Holly get really warm and don’t make much sense initially but then they delve into ROYAL MURDERS. They discuss the murder of the Earl of Erroll (mouthful to say) otherwise known as Josslyn Hay and the murder of King George V. There’s sex, drugs but not much rock and roll. We find out that Gemma’s story includes Holly’s Royal relative, discuss the excessive use of Royal titles, and debate the benefits of euthanasia. We also find out that Holly nearly died one time! Listen
9: EPISODE 9: MEDIEVAL
In episode nine Gemma and Holly cover two medieval murderers: Elizabeth Bathory the Blood Countess and Peter Stumpf the Werewolf of Bedburg….from the Medieval period. They discuss how to escape the stomach of a dead horse, why freezing to death is the worst, Holly solves religious warfare with ice cream, and the Medieval Period is repeatedly declared DUMB. Find out which ‘probably not a murderer but we will never know because Medieval times were dumb’ murderer we would pick to knock us off out o
8: EPISODE 8: CHILDREN WHO MURDER
In episode eight Holly and Gemma cover two children who committed murder: James Arcene and Craig Price….the literal poster children for birth control. They talk about why kids are so difficult, the rules of murder club, Holly gives stabbing advice and how easily children fit through prison bars. Find out which underage murderer we would pick to knock us off out of the these terrible choices.Our cat tickler Craig is responsible for the recording, production and editing stuff. We think he uses a c
7: EPISODE 7: UNSOLVED
In episode seven Gemma and Holly cover two unsolved murders: the Black Dahlia (Elizabeth Short) and Vera Page....and basically solve them both through pure assumption and scientific guesswork. They talk about cute 1930's names, disturbing childhood memories, the pros and cons of being cut in half and projectile dog pooping. Find out which murderer we would pick to knock us off out of the these terrible unsolved choices.Holly did the editing on this one – with one million wrong button pushes and
6/2: EPISODE 6, PART 2: CULTASTIC
In episode 6 Holly and Gemma pull a two-parter to cover off cults, discuss their message from a murderer’s relative and contemplate the cults of Manson Family, as well as the People’s Temple.They talk about the worst sunglass wearing phase of humankind, a very expensive STD treatment, muppet buses and screw up geography. Find out which cult we would have joined if we had to join a cult. Which we totally would.Sound prophet Craig recorded, produced and edited this episode using his own special bl
6/1: EPISODE 6, PART 1: CULTASTIC
In episode 6 Holly and Gemma pull a two-parter to cover off cults, discuss their message from a murderer’s relative and contemplate the cults of Manson Family, as well as the People’s Temple.They talk about the worst sunglass wearing phase of humankind, a very expensive STD treatment, muppet buses and screw up geography. Find out which cult we would have joined if we had to join a cult. Which we totally would.Sound prophet Craig recorded, produced and edited this episode using his own special bl
5: EPISODE 5: EDINBURGH SPECIAL
In episode five Gemma and Holly forget what a podcast is….and how to speak words from their word holes…..borrow a suggestion from Facepage, then cover Edinburgh murderers Ian Sutherland and Ernst Dumoulin.They talk about the best places to pass out in a field in Edinburgh, debate the criminal justice system – AGAIN – sneeze, and chat through how snakes swallow people. Find out which UK murderer we would pick to knock us off out of the two terrible choices.Holly is responsible for the questionabl
4: EPISODE 4: UK MURDERERS
In episode four Holly and Gemma cover UK murderers James Lunney and John Christie....although technically Gemma cheated with her Isle of Man case. She’s been punished. We talk about how math ruins people’s lives, Willy Wonka, the death penalty and terribly packaged men. Find out which UK murderer we would pick to knock us off out of the these terrible choices.Our sound genie and cat wrangler Craig is responsible for the bad-ass recording, post-production and editing. We think he uses a combinati
3: EPISODE 3: OLD TIMEY
In episode three, Holly and Gemma travel back to the old timey times….talking about legends, murderers who got super snacky, farm S&M and the worst pretend nurse. Ever. Find out which old timey murderer we would pick to knock us off out of the these terrible choices.Recording, post-production and editing for this episode done terribly with zero skill and endless butt clenching at having to listen to her own voice for hours on end, by Holly.www.whichmurderer.comWARNING - Explicit language, conten
2: EPISODE 2: TWO FOR ONE
In episode two Gemma and Holly cover couples Gwendolyn Graham and Cathy Wood, as well as Amanda Baggus and David Lehane....murderers who found true love with other psychopaths. There is definitely a dating app opportunity here....WE CLAIM ALL RIGHTS. There are terrible trophy choices, garden shed prisoners and a special appearance by Cleo. The asshole cat. Find out which murdery couple we would pick to knock us off out of the these terrible choices.Recording, post-production and editing done wit
1: EPISODE 1: CANADIAN BACON
In episode one, Holly and Gemma cover **Robert 'Willie' Pickton** and **Gilbert Paul Jordan**....who were both absolute pricks. We talk pig farms, personal connections, barbers and how an overachieving alcoholic used his one God given skill to murder people. Find out which murderer we would pick to knock us off out of the two terrible choices.Recording, post-production and editing done with so much thanks that he is basically guaranteed a kidney on demand, by Craig. We think he uses a combinatio
Introducing Holly & Gemma from Which Murderer
Holly and Gemma introduce themselves and give a little taste of what the upcoming podcast **Which Murderer** is all about, including a brief description of **Episode 1: 'Canadian Bacon'**Holly makes up facts that aren't true about her first murderer, Gemma picks the best nicknamed murderer ever....and both probably make enemies of two governments in one shot. Subscribe on iTunes and Stitcher or visit our website www.whichmurderer.com